As the Weekly first reported in February, Tanaka received $47,895 in late contributions (those reported after the November election), which was more than half of the total his campaign raised. Most of the late cash came from developers and property managers, a few of whom gave the campaign $5,000 checks.
Tanaka is one of three council members who benefitted from the late surge of developer cash. Vice Mayor Liz Kniss and Councilman Adrian Fine also reported contributions from the builder community after their election and both are also subjects of anonymous complaints, according to the FPPC. The agency has opened an investigation into Kniss' campaign (see article on page 5) but has not indicated whether Fine will be investigated.
Tanaka previously told the Weekly that he was not involved with his campaign's fundraising and that his campaign had not done anything improper. He could not be reached for comment for this story.
The Feb. 27 letter from the FPPC to Tanaka cites three potential violations that are being looked at. It notes that Tanaka was the "recipient of an approximately 13-foot campaign sign mounted atop the building of the architect for 429 University Ave.," a development that the council was set to review in February (and which it ultimately approved). The building is being developed by the family of Elizabeth Wong, whose son Andrew Wong contributed $5,000 to Tanaka.
The other two violations are more general in nature. One notes that Tanaka's filings leave blank the occupations of several developers, including Chop Keenan, Jim Baer, Chasen Rapp, Mark Gates Jr., Joseph Martinetti, Jr., and Perry Palmer.
"These inaccurate filings allowed Mr. Tanaka to conceal the amount of donations he received from real-estate developers and mislead the voting public," the complaint alleges, according to the letter from the FPPC.
In addition, the FPPC cites a personal loan Tanaka made to his campaign, which was later paid back from late donations, according to the FPPC letter.
"The reporting of this transaction hid the source of his campaign financing from the voters," the letter states. "Because these late donations reimbursed the candidate's personal loan to his campaign, should these donations instead be classified as gifts and have triggered a recusal on the Wong property vote."
The concerns in the complaint hew closely to those made by Michael Harbour, a downtown property owner who appealed the council's prior approval of 429 University, and various members of the group Palo Altans for Sensible Zoning. Before the Feb. 6 discussion of 429 University, several speakers called for Tanaka to recuse himself. The fact that Tanaka said he had returned the $5,000 to Andrew Wong — citing the "proximity of time" between the donation and the review — did not assuage these concerns.
"I encourage you to recuse yourself, even though you refunded it," downtown resident Andrew Gottlieb told Tanaka during the public-comment portion of the meeting. "It creates a cloud and appearance of impropriety, which undermines the public's confidence in the process."
But after publicly confirming with City Attorney Molly Stump that he was not legally required to recuse himself from the discussion, Tanaka decided to participate. Later in the meeting, he was one of five council members to vote in favor of the revised project, which passed by a 5-3 vote.
The letter from the FPPC notes that at this time, it has "not made any determinations."
"We are simply providing you with this information and will be contacting you again to regarding this matter," the letter states.
TALK ABOUT IT
People are discussing this article on Town Square, the online discussion forum. See what they have to say and share your own views by going to PaloAltoOnline.com/square.
This story contains 700 words.
Stories older than 90 days are available only to subscribing members. Please help sustain quality local journalism by becoming a subscribing member today.
If you are already a subscriber, please log in so you can continue to enjoy unlimited access to stories and archives. Subscriptions start at $5 per month and may be cancelled at any time.