Questions persist about Palo Alto basements | September 26, 2008 | Palo Alto Weekly | Palo Alto Online |

Palo Alto Weekly

News - September 26, 2008

Questions persist about Palo Alto basements

Concrete, 'dewatering' are key issues for planning commission and some residents

by Becky Trout

Many questions remain unanswered about basement construction in Palo Alto, the Planning and Transportation Commission agreed Wednesday night.

Without a vote, the commission postponed potentially recommending restrictions until a later meeting.

Some commissioners and residents remain concerned about the massive amounts of water — as much as 12 million gallons — pumped out when residents decide to add basements to their homes. Basements also require about 300 tons of concrete, a significant source of greenhouse-gas emissions.

"I can tell you that a lot of people in town are indignant," resident Ellen Wyman said. Her neighbors have had trees die, foundations shift and old basements begin flooding after the construction of new basements, she said.

"When that many people perceive it as a problem, it's a problem."

Yet if the city makes it harder to build basements, homeowners will be more inclined to build out or up, resident Norman Beamer said.

"It will significantly decrease the value of the property," he said.

About three to seven residential basements are constructed per year in Palo Alto that require water pumping, said Bob Morris, the city's senior public-works project manager.

The city now restricts "dewatering" to April through October to prevent overstressing the storm-drain system, Morris said.

But the city hasn't found any pervasive problems — for trees, foundations or the groundwater, according to Curtis Williams, the city's interim planning and transportation director.

"It's not a pervasive type of concern we hear from neighbors," Williams said.

And even if dewatering did affect a nearby residence, the city couldn't do anything, Chief Building Official Larry Perlin said.

"It becomes really that one property owner is being harmed by the actions of another property owner. The two property owners have to resolve that amongst themselves," Perlin said.

The commission could require basements to be set back from property lines, limit the amount of water removed or the time pumping can be done, or it could require basement builders to add additional environmental features to their house to offset the effects of the concrete, a city report states.

Staff Writer Becky Trout can be e-mailed at


Posted by Heiniman and Sons, a resident of Downtown North
on Oct 1, 2008 at 7:42 pm

Perhaps before making irrevalent statements regarding law issues, Building Official Larry Perlin might want to read up on the law regarding property rights. Hope we can count on you using your statement in court.

Posted by Vince, a resident of Old Palo Alto
on Oct 12, 2008 at 10:21 pm

It is not okay to pump out ground water for sometimes up to two years. How can it be allowed? How can this issue have been ignored for so long?