M-A now meets Hillsborough on Monday in the winners'-bracket semifinals. Hillsborough beat San Carlos, 6-5, in Wednesday's other game. In the other winners'-bracket semi on Monday, Half Moon Bay will play San Mateo American. All games are at Ortega School in Pacifica.
Time seemed to stand still when Elefritz, the tallest player on the M-A team, made his catch in left; falling back into the plastic netting that serves as the outfield fence and landing on the other side, but hanging on to the ball. The silence was broken by someone in the M-A dugout, who yelled: "He caught it!"
For the record, that someone was Toig.
"When Joe got back to the dugout, we were all mobbing him," said Toig, whose double in the bottom of the inning drove in O'Donnell, who had walked. "We were so excited. Alpine is our big rival. We're all friends, and a lot of those guys go to the same schools as we do."
Toig, in fact, attends St. Joseph's with one of Alpine's players, Justin Harmon.
It's usually Alpine which has had the bragging rights in this rivalry, but not so far this year. It was a Menlo-Atherton team, Mike's Cafe, which won Menlo Park's annual City Championship game over a team from the Alpine/West Menlo league last week. And now it was M-A that has sent Alpine to the losers' bracket (Alpine will play again on Friday).
M-A struck for three runs in the first on a run-scoring double by Jack Gray and run-scoring singles by Kyle Bryan and Will Johnson. But Alpine starter John Bird shut the door after that, retiring eight straight and 11 of the next 12 he faced.
Meanwhile, Alpine chipped away. Evan Easton drove home a run with a single in the second, Matt Henefarth did the same with a groundout in the third, and Mitch Martella (2-for-3) singled and scored on a throwing error to tie it in the sixth.
But it wasn't quite enough.
"That was amazing," said O'Donnell of Elefritz's catch. O'Donnell pitched three innings of strong relief, which included getting out of a no-out, two-on jam in the fifth with two strikeouts. "I was scared that the ball was going to drop over for a home run."
When Elefritz got back to the dugout after the catch, he patted O'Donnell on the shoulder as if to say, 'I had it all the way.'
"He saved everything," O'Donnell said. "It feels good. It's really nice to beat your rival."
Palo Alto National and Alpine/West Menlo remained alive in the District 52 consolation bracket in San Mateo.
Palo Alto National eliminated Palo Alto American with a 13-1 victory. Christian Laurence gave American its own run with a solo homer in the first. PA National bounced back quickly with a run in the first to tie, then took the lead in the third with nine runs.
Justin Jull, Griffy Byer and Pete Snodgrass all had two hits for the winners. Tommy Smale got the pitching win for PA National, which next plays on Friday at 5:30 p.m.
Alpine/West Menlo stayed alive by rallying from a 12-6 deficit in the bottom of the sixth. Alpine scored three times for a 12-9 game and had the bases loaded when Jack Molumphy hit a grand slam to win the game. Alpine also will play Friday at 5:30 p.m.
Palo Alto National remained unbeaten following a wild 12-8 come-from-behind victory over Menlo-Atherton on Tuesday at Marina Field at the Belmont Sports Complex. Palo Alto next will play Friday against either Hillsborough or San Mateo National (7:30 p.m.), needing a victory to advance to the semifinals.
The 9-10s trailed 8-0 before coming to bat in the bottom of the first inning. Palo Alto scraped together four runs in the first two innings, made it an 8-7 game in the fourth and finally pulled ahead for good with five runs in the fifth.
After loading the bases in the fifth, Noah Yuen slapped an RBI single to tie the game at 8. When the ball was mishandled in right field, Patrick Welch raced home with the eventual winning run. Jonathan Gottlieb singled in his third run of the game and Ole Erickson followed with his third RBI (a single) of the game.
Palo Alto added another insurance run, more than enough to give the pitching victory to Max Jung-Goldberg. Gottlieb was the real pitching standout for Palo Alto as he held M-A scoreless with four innings of relief. He also had a two-run single in the fourth to help his team close the gap.
The teams committed a combined 13 errors. Palo Alto had five in the first inning to help M-A score its eight runs. Only two runs were earned. Menlo-Atherton also committed five errors in the first, helping Palo Alto to its pair of runs.
This story contains 927 words.
Stories older than 90 days are available only to subscribing members. Please help sustain quality local journalism by becoming a subscribing member today.
If you are already a subscriber, please log in so you can continue to enjoy unlimited access to stories and archives. Subscriptions start at $5 per month and may be cancelled at any time.