News

Pandemic-induced enrollment plunge persists for second year at local public schools

Local private schools see a big jump in applications

Eighth graders work on an exercise in their Spanish 1B class at Ellen Fletcher Middle School in Palo Alto on Nov. 17, 2021. Photo by Magali Gauthier.

Local public schools are still seeing dwindling enrollment tied to the pandemic, but the drops were not as significant as last year. A silver lining for some private schools has been a big increase in applications.

The Almanac and Palo Alto Weekly teamed up for a data project to examine eight years' worth of enrollment figures for local school districts. Although schools have generally seen enrollment decline in recent years, the pandemic dramatically accelerated that trend in many districts.

California public school districts collect enrollment data every October. Because the state hasn't released final numbers for this school year, the 2021-22 data was self-reported by school districts to the Weekly and Almanac. Data from prior years is based on California Department of Education records. This school year's numbers may shift slightly as the data is finalized.

School administrators attribute enrollment decreases in part to families moving out of the area due to skyrocketing housing costs, now that many parents can work remotely, and also to students choosing to attend charter schools.

The 2020 U.S. Census also shows the number of young people on the Midpeninsula is shrinking, even as the overall population grows.

What's local journalism worth to you?

Support Palo Alto Online for as little as $5/month.

Join

Because most Midpeninsula school districts are funded primarily with local property taxes, rather than based on the number of students, the enrollment decline doesn't translate into less money for these districts. As long as property tax revenue doesn't decrease, districts will end up with more money for each remaining student.

Palo Alto Unified School District

Social studies teacher Nicole Bliss speaks with her seventh grade students at Ellen Fletcher Middle School in Palo Alto on Nov. 17, 2021. With enrollment shrinking at the middle school, the Palo Alto Unified School District is considering running an intra-district lottery for the school next school year. Photo by Magali Gauthier.

The Palo Alto Unified School District saw its enrollment drop by nearly 1,000 students last school year over the prior fall, and then by another roughly 275 this fall. The school district currently has 10,476 pupils.

Before the pandemic, the district was seeing its numbers dip, but more slowly. Palo Alto saw 2.1% declines in enrollment in each of the two school years preceding the pandemic.

As with many districts, Palo Alto's enrollment plunged in the fall of 2020, declining 8.4%. Superintendent Don Austin said that although many districts expected to see a rebound this fall, he took a more conservative approach and thought it was likely to stay flat. Instead, enrollment dropped another 2.6%.

"I did not expect a big rebound, but yeah, it was a little bit of a surprise that we were down again," Austin said.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox in our Express newsletter.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox in our Express newsletter.

The decline in Palo Alto's student body is more pronounced in some areas of the district. Barron Park Elementary School now has fewer than 200 students, compared to Escondido Elementary, which has more than 450. Ellen Fletcher Middle School has roughly 500, which is much lower than the 800 to 1,000 students at each of the district's other two middle schools. Both Fletcher and Barron Park sit in the southeast corner of the district.

Fletcher's shrinking population has prompted the district to consider running a lottery for the school next year, which would allow families in other parts of the district to apply to have their children attend Fletcher. The district's board supported that possibility at a Nov. 16 board meeting.

Districts seeing declining enrollment pre-pandemic

Kindergarten teacher Ruth Cuellar gives Regina some hand sanitizer before entering the classroom on the first day of school at Los Robles-Ronald McNair Academy in East Palo Alto on Aug. 25, 2021. Photo by Magali Gauthier.

The K-8 Ravenswood City School District, which has schools in East Palo Alto and Menlo Park, had the region's "most severe" enrollment decline prepandemic, according to the San Mateo-based Enrollment Projection Consultants. District officials declined to comment when asked about enrollment figures.

Students enrolled at charters authorized by the district ballooned from 18% in the 2014-15 school year to 45.4% this school year. The district has seen a nearly 44% decline in non-charter school enrollment (1,501 students are enrolled) since the 2017-18 school year. There are 260 fewer students enrolled in the district's non-charter schools this fall.

Students are choosing the charter schools KIPP Valiant Community Prep and Aspire East Palo Alto, and the private Primary School in East Palo Alto. This means the district loses students and the government funding affiliated with them. The district is one of the few primarily state-funded districts on the Midpeninsula.

The Los Altos School District's enrollment has been declining for years, but during the pandemic that trend has accelerated. Last school year, the number of students attending district schools dropped by double digits (10.6%). This fall, there was another 6.5% decrease. In total, the district's enrollment has fallen from 3,999 students in 2019 to 3,344 today.

Superintendent Jeff Baier said some students moved out of the state, with others moving to other parts of California and some switching to private or charter schools. The pandemic has also made it more difficult to track where students end up, Baier said.

The district's numbers don't account for Bullis Charter School, which the state doesn't include in the Los Altos School District's enrollment total. Although Bullis is located within the district's boundaries, it is overseen by the Santa Clara County Office of Education.

Bullis' enrollment increased 5.2% last school year (from 1,039 students in 2019 to 1,093 in 2020). This year, it decreased 2.4% to 1,067 students. The charter school's enrollment is currently capped at 1,111 students under the terms of an agreement with the Los Altos School District.

Mountain View Whisman School District

Enrollment in the Mountain View Whisman School District dropped 6.5% last fall compared to the prior year, and then by another 5.1% this school year. In total, the district has gone from 5,082 students in 2019 to 4,511 this fall.

That's in contrast to the years before the pandemic, when the district's enrollment was holding relatively steady. The number of students was fluctuating only slightly year to year, with a net change of just two students between the fall of 2015 (5,084 students) and 2019 (5,082).

Superintendent Ayinde Rudolph said that besides families voluntarily leaving, the recent demolition of a number of apartment complexes in Mountain View may have forced other families to relocate.

'The pandemic was a perfect storm of a multitude of events that created a drop in enrollment.'

-Ayinde Rudolph, superintendent, Mountain View Whisman School District

"The pandemic was a perfect storm of a multitude of events that created a drop in enrollment," he said.

The district did see some students who withdrew last year come back this fall, even as the district's overall population continued to drop, Rudolph said.

Despite the current drop in enrollment, Mountain View Whisman officials continue to project a long-term increase in students as a result of planned housing growth in Mountain View. State housing targets call for the city to plan for 11,135 housing units between 2023 and 2031.

High school district outliers

The Mountain View Los Altos Union High School District is one of the few local school districts that was seeing its student body grow before the pandemic hit, but for the past two years, the district's enrollment has essentially flatlined.

Last fall, the district had just 15 more students than the year before, which works out to a 0.3% increase. In total, the student body sat at 4,563. This year, the district saw its enrollment drop for the first time in at least eight years, with a 1% decrease to 4,516 students.

That's a marked difference from what MVLA was experiencing before COVID-19 disrupted education. In the five years from 2015 to 2019, the district's enrollment shot up by over 500 students.

Freshman Maya Sofia Estrada works during a Spanish class at TIDE Academy in Menlo Park on Oct. 27, 2021. Photo by Magali Gauthier.

Overall enrollment in the Sequoia Union High School District increased almost 1% from the 2019-20 (10,238 students) to 2020-21 (10,327 students) school years. Preliminary 2021-22 data shows enrollment decreased by about 2% (to 10,109 students) from last year.

Individual schools in the district, like Woodside and Menlo-Atherton high schools, saw declining enrollment over the last two years.

Woodside has seen about an 11% dip in enrollment (1,752 students this school year) from the 2018-19 school year (1,964 students). This school year, 2,226 students are enrolled at M-A in Atherton, down from 2,368 last fall, an over 6% drop.

Small school districts

Portola Valley Elementary School District administrators formed a study group in response to their enrollment dip — PVSD has 477 students, down more than 13% from the fall of 2019-20, according to Superintendent Roberta Zarea.

The group will study enrollment trends in Portola Valley and comparable local school districts, facilities capacity, student demographics, performance data, how to attract and retain students and more. They will make recommendations to Zarea and the governing board.

Erika Rodriguez arrives on the Laurel School campus with her son Paulo Cortez, 5, who is starting kindergarten in Atherton on Aug. 19, 2021. Photo by Magali Gauthier.

Enrollment is down 2.3% from last school year, to 2,716 students, in the Menlo Park City School District. In September, Superintendent Erik Burmeister explained that some families re-enrolled last spring for the fall term, but ultimately dropped out. It's rare to have this level of attrition between re-enrollment and the beginning of the school year, he said.

"It's safe to say this is a temporary decline in student enrollment," he said. "Some folks don't want to come (to school) in person until COVID is in the rearview mirror."

Las Lomitas Elementary School District, which has one school in Menlo Park and one in Atherton, "lost families during the pandemic to people moving and a few learning pods, who ultimately returned," said Superintendent Beth Polito in an email. The Las Lomitas Elementary School District has 1,099 students enrolled this year, down about 9% from the fall of 2019 (1,208 students).

"A portion of (the) continued enrollment decline is the loss of international families who largely worked/studied at Stanford (University)," she noted.

The one-school Woodside Elementary School District has 365 students. Enrollment is down almost 11% from the 2018-19 school year.

Applications rise at local private schools

Forbes reported last June that the pandemic bolstered private school enrollment when parents saw how differently private schools handled learning at the onset of the pandemic.

Although some local elementary-aged students last fall returned to classrooms, at least on a hybrid basis, many public high school students did not. On the other hand, many private schools resumed full-time in-person learning during the last school year.

"The pandemic revealed a view behind the 'school system' curtain, which promulgated some families to move and to change education paths," said Karen Aronian, a parenting and education expert, in an email. "The whiplash turnstile of remote, hybrid, in-school, quarantine, and repeat has left public schools, their students, and communities in a tailspin of logistical protocols and uncertainties."

Menlo School in Atherton was open for in-person learning sooner than the comprehensive high schools.

Menlo School students eat lunch outdoors on the Atherton campus on Oct. 26, 2020. Courtesy Menlo School.

The private school, which serves sixth through 12th grade students, has "seen an uptick in admissions interest since the pandemic started," said Alex Perez, its director of media relations. Menlo has seen a 10% increase in applications over the last two years, he noted. The school has 795 students enrolled, according to its website.

"It's a record year for us," he said. "We have certainly seen greater demand from families who are seeking an independent school education."

Amory Healy, a sophomore at Menlo School, transferred from Palo Alto High School this school year, in part because she didn't feel like her public high school had the resources available to support her.

"At Paly, there were around 30 people in each class, and many teachers were so busy that there wasn't really time for students to reach out and get extra help," she said. "I think as well with how competitive college admissions are, having a school that gives easy opportunities to obtain leadership opportunities and provides great college counselors is a very popular plus side of private schools."

Trinity School on Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park has seen a 36% increase in applications since the pandemic hit, said Kirk W. Gossman, director of admission.

The Episcopal school has seen a significant increase in applications across the board. It's also seen an increased number of transfer requests from public school families for this school year.

"We thought these kids may return to the public (school) sector once those schools reopened but instead, they stayed and brought siblings to join them," he said in an email.

The number of applications to Pinewood School, which has three campuses in Los Altos, has increased 20% across grades K-12, said Lisa Longbottom, director of admissions, in an email. The school enrolls 600 students.

A front row seat to local high school sports.

Check out our new newsletter, the Playbook.

Angela Swartz writes for The Almanac, a sister publication of PaloAltoOnline.com.

Follow Palo Alto Online and the Palo Alto Weekly on Twitter @paloaltoweekly, Facebook and on Instagram @paloaltoonline for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Stay informed on important education news. Sign up for our FREE daily Express newsletter.

Pandemic-induced enrollment plunge persists for second year at local public schools

Local private schools see a big jump in applications

by / Palo Alto Weekly

Uploaded: Fri, Nov 19, 2021, 6:51 am
Updated: Mon, Nov 22, 2021, 8:54 am

Local public schools are still seeing dwindling enrollment tied to the pandemic, but the drops were not as significant as last year. A silver lining for some private schools has been a big increase in applications.

The Almanac and Palo Alto Weekly teamed up for a data project to examine eight years' worth of enrollment figures for local school districts. Although schools have generally seen enrollment decline in recent years, the pandemic dramatically accelerated that trend in many districts.

California public school districts collect enrollment data every October. Because the state hasn't released final numbers for this school year, the 2021-22 data was self-reported by school districts to the Weekly and Almanac. Data from prior years is based on California Department of Education records. This school year's numbers may shift slightly as the data is finalized.

School administrators attribute enrollment decreases in part to families moving out of the area due to skyrocketing housing costs, now that many parents can work remotely, and also to students choosing to attend charter schools.

The 2020 U.S. Census also shows the number of young people on the Midpeninsula is shrinking, even as the overall population grows.

Because most Midpeninsula school districts are funded primarily with local property taxes, rather than based on the number of students, the enrollment decline doesn't translate into less money for these districts. As long as property tax revenue doesn't decrease, districts will end up with more money for each remaining student.

The Palo Alto Unified School District saw its enrollment drop by nearly 1,000 students last school year over the prior fall, and then by another roughly 275 this fall. The school district currently has 10,476 pupils.

Before the pandemic, the district was seeing its numbers dip, but more slowly. Palo Alto saw 2.1% declines in enrollment in each of the two school years preceding the pandemic.

As with many districts, Palo Alto's enrollment plunged in the fall of 2020, declining 8.4%. Superintendent Don Austin said that although many districts expected to see a rebound this fall, he took a more conservative approach and thought it was likely to stay flat. Instead, enrollment dropped another 2.6%.

"I did not expect a big rebound, but yeah, it was a little bit of a surprise that we were down again," Austin said.

The decline in Palo Alto's student body is more pronounced in some areas of the district. Barron Park Elementary School now has fewer than 200 students, compared to Escondido Elementary, which has more than 450. Ellen Fletcher Middle School has roughly 500, which is much lower than the 800 to 1,000 students at each of the district's other two middle schools. Both Fletcher and Barron Park sit in the southeast corner of the district.

Fletcher's shrinking population has prompted the district to consider running a lottery for the school next year, which would allow families in other parts of the district to apply to have their children attend Fletcher. The district's board supported that possibility at a Nov. 16 board meeting.

The K-8 Ravenswood City School District, which has schools in East Palo Alto and Menlo Park, had the region's "most severe" enrollment decline prepandemic, according to the San Mateo-based Enrollment Projection Consultants. District officials declined to comment when asked about enrollment figures.

Students enrolled at charters authorized by the district ballooned from 18% in the 2014-15 school year to 45.4% this school year. The district has seen a nearly 44% decline in non-charter school enrollment (1,501 students are enrolled) since the 2017-18 school year. There are 260 fewer students enrolled in the district's non-charter schools this fall.

Students are choosing the charter schools KIPP Valiant Community Prep and Aspire East Palo Alto, and the private Primary School in East Palo Alto. This means the district loses students and the government funding affiliated with them. The district is one of the few primarily state-funded districts on the Midpeninsula.

The Los Altos School District's enrollment has been declining for years, but during the pandemic that trend has accelerated. Last school year, the number of students attending district schools dropped by double digits (10.6%). This fall, there was another 6.5% decrease. In total, the district's enrollment has fallen from 3,999 students in 2019 to 3,344 today.

Superintendent Jeff Baier said some students moved out of the state, with others moving to other parts of California and some switching to private or charter schools. The pandemic has also made it more difficult to track where students end up, Baier said.

The district's numbers don't account for Bullis Charter School, which the state doesn't include in the Los Altos School District's enrollment total. Although Bullis is located within the district's boundaries, it is overseen by the Santa Clara County Office of Education.

Bullis' enrollment increased 5.2% last school year (from 1,039 students in 2019 to 1,093 in 2020). This year, it decreased 2.4% to 1,067 students. The charter school's enrollment is currently capped at 1,111 students under the terms of an agreement with the Los Altos School District.

Enrollment in the Mountain View Whisman School District dropped 6.5% last fall compared to the prior year, and then by another 5.1% this school year. In total, the district has gone from 5,082 students in 2019 to 4,511 this fall.

That's in contrast to the years before the pandemic, when the district's enrollment was holding relatively steady. The number of students was fluctuating only slightly year to year, with a net change of just two students between the fall of 2015 (5,084 students) and 2019 (5,082).

Superintendent Ayinde Rudolph said that besides families voluntarily leaving, the recent demolition of a number of apartment complexes in Mountain View may have forced other families to relocate.

"The pandemic was a perfect storm of a multitude of events that created a drop in enrollment," he said.

The district did see some students who withdrew last year come back this fall, even as the district's overall population continued to drop, Rudolph said.

Despite the current drop in enrollment, Mountain View Whisman officials continue to project a long-term increase in students as a result of planned housing growth in Mountain View. State housing targets call for the city to plan for 11,135 housing units between 2023 and 2031.

The Mountain View Los Altos Union High School District is one of the few local school districts that was seeing its student body grow before the pandemic hit, but for the past two years, the district's enrollment has essentially flatlined.

Last fall, the district had just 15 more students than the year before, which works out to a 0.3% increase. In total, the student body sat at 4,563. This year, the district saw its enrollment drop for the first time in at least eight years, with a 1% decrease to 4,516 students.

That's a marked difference from what MVLA was experiencing before COVID-19 disrupted education. In the five years from 2015 to 2019, the district's enrollment shot up by over 500 students.

Overall enrollment in the Sequoia Union High School District increased almost 1% from the 2019-20 (10,238 students) to 2020-21 (10,327 students) school years. Preliminary 2021-22 data shows enrollment decreased by about 2% (to 10,109 students) from last year.

Individual schools in the district, like Woodside and Menlo-Atherton high schools, saw declining enrollment over the last two years.

Woodside has seen about an 11% dip in enrollment (1,752 students this school year) from the 2018-19 school year (1,964 students). This school year, 2,226 students are enrolled at M-A in Atherton, down from 2,368 last fall, an over 6% drop.

Portola Valley Elementary School District administrators formed a study group in response to their enrollment dip — PVSD has 477 students, down more than 13% from the fall of 2019-20, according to Superintendent Roberta Zarea.

The group will study enrollment trends in Portola Valley and comparable local school districts, facilities capacity, student demographics, performance data, how to attract and retain students and more. They will make recommendations to Zarea and the governing board.

Enrollment is down 2.3% from last school year, to 2,716 students, in the Menlo Park City School District. In September, Superintendent Erik Burmeister explained that some families re-enrolled last spring for the fall term, but ultimately dropped out. It's rare to have this level of attrition between re-enrollment and the beginning of the school year, he said.

"It's safe to say this is a temporary decline in student enrollment," he said. "Some folks don't want to come (to school) in person until COVID is in the rearview mirror."

Las Lomitas Elementary School District, which has one school in Menlo Park and one in Atherton, "lost families during the pandemic to people moving and a few learning pods, who ultimately returned," said Superintendent Beth Polito in an email. The Las Lomitas Elementary School District has 1,099 students enrolled this year, down about 9% from the fall of 2019 (1,208 students).

"A portion of (the) continued enrollment decline is the loss of international families who largely worked/studied at Stanford (University)," she noted.

The one-school Woodside Elementary School District has 365 students. Enrollment is down almost 11% from the 2018-19 school year.

Forbes reported last June that the pandemic bolstered private school enrollment when parents saw how differently private schools handled learning at the onset of the pandemic.

Although some local elementary-aged students last fall returned to classrooms, at least on a hybrid basis, many public high school students did not. On the other hand, many private schools resumed full-time in-person learning during the last school year.

"The pandemic revealed a view behind the 'school system' curtain, which promulgated some families to move and to change education paths," said Karen Aronian, a parenting and education expert, in an email. "The whiplash turnstile of remote, hybrid, in-school, quarantine, and repeat has left public schools, their students, and communities in a tailspin of logistical protocols and uncertainties."

Menlo School in Atherton was open for in-person learning sooner than the comprehensive high schools.

The private school, which serves sixth through 12th grade students, has "seen an uptick in admissions interest since the pandemic started," said Alex Perez, its director of media relations. Menlo has seen a 10% increase in applications over the last two years, he noted. The school has 795 students enrolled, according to its website.

"It's a record year for us," he said. "We have certainly seen greater demand from families who are seeking an independent school education."

Amory Healy, a sophomore at Menlo School, transferred from Palo Alto High School this school year, in part because she didn't feel like her public high school had the resources available to support her.

"At Paly, there were around 30 people in each class, and many teachers were so busy that there wasn't really time for students to reach out and get extra help," she said. "I think as well with how competitive college admissions are, having a school that gives easy opportunities to obtain leadership opportunities and provides great college counselors is a very popular plus side of private schools."

Trinity School on Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park has seen a 36% increase in applications since the pandemic hit, said Kirk W. Gossman, director of admission.

The Episcopal school has seen a significant increase in applications across the board. It's also seen an increased number of transfer requests from public school families for this school year.

"We thought these kids may return to the public (school) sector once those schools reopened but instead, they stayed and brought siblings to join them," he said in an email.

The number of applications to Pinewood School, which has three campuses in Los Altos, has increased 20% across grades K-12, said Lisa Longbottom, director of admissions, in an email. The school enrolls 600 students.

Angela Swartz writes for The Almanac, a sister publication of PaloAltoOnline.com.

Comments

Citizen
Registered user
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Nov 19, 2021 at 5:33 pm
Citizen, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
Registered user
on Nov 19, 2021 at 5:33 pm

"...the number of young people on the Midpeninsula is shrinking, even as the overall population grows."

This was SO obviously going to happen. All this developer-supported clamoring for more "housing" in this arid, overcrowded region on the false premise that just building will make things affordable has only pushed families (and people of color) out, and destroyed quality of life that made families willing to sacrifice to stay here in the past.

Even the idea that making "affordable" microspaces will make families return or not leave is flawed; surveys of millenials show a majority want single-family homes, too. People leave the area to find a better quality of life they can afford, people have forever commuted long distances to find a better QUALITY OF LIFE they can afford here; affordable microspaces (nevermind the pie-in-the-sky economic arguments) aren't it.

We do not benefit from destroying what's good here to become a dormitory monoculture for just-out young people in the tech industry whose desires, lack of community engagement & high relative salaries negatively impact everyone else already living here (and their companies who do not pay local taxes) and who will move on when they want a reasonable quality of life & families, too. (And btw, an MIT study found the AVERAGE age of successful startup founder is 45.)

Reductions in school enrollments were easy to see coming a mile away. In the past, economic booms filled our schools and people were willing to sacrifice to stay here for the schools. But our schools have not kept up with the times, esp in the pandemic.

If our district had the smarts to develop a real hybrid independent study program that took the best of flexibility/customization for students, distance learning where desired/necessary AND careful IN-PERSON social and teacher connections/after school/sports/mentorship, PAUSD would not have lost so many students. They've been pushing out the "undesirables' for so long; now they got their wish.


S. Underwood
Registered user
Crescent Park
on Nov 19, 2021 at 6:31 pm
S. Underwood, Crescent Park
Registered user
on Nov 19, 2021 at 6:31 pm

Private enrollments aren't down. They're up.

Ergo, PAUSD can't place the blame for this latest turn on the pandemic or regional demographic shifts, both of which apply to privates equally. [In fact, privates got substantially LESS outside support in response to the pandemic.]

PAUSD is now a fraction of the quality and brilliance it once was. The senior admin and the Board have been driving us this way for some time. The Weekly minimizes, in my opinion, because it's tough to advertise homes from $9,9 and $3,2 million (literally the ads in my side bar as I type this) next to a constant stream of articles about how the school district is a disaster... assaults, diminished academics, math discrimination, fleeing families, and so on...


RDR
Registered user
another community
on Nov 20, 2021 at 3:10 pm
RDR, another community
Registered user
on Nov 20, 2021 at 3:10 pm

The school age population decline is NATIONWIDE. It's very evident across the state of California. Mercury News article the other day reported statewide drop off of 250,000 students over the past 5 years, and a projection of a continued drop off of 500,000 more over the next 10 years.

So it's not the pandemic mainly, and not the quality of the schools.


chris
Registered user
University South
on Nov 20, 2021 at 10:52 pm
chris, University South
Registered user
on Nov 20, 2021 at 10:52 pm

Simitian's attempt to extort a school from Stanford for PAUSD was totally unfounded.


Palo Alto Res
Registered user
Downtown North
on Nov 22, 2021 at 6:18 am
Palo Alto Res, Downtown North
Registered user
on Nov 22, 2021 at 6:18 am

Just wait until the Millennials start having children, then there will be a huge uptick in population. Millennials having babies is just around the corner. That demographic group is larger than the Boomers.

Don't understand why Palo Alto High School is having classrooms of 30 kids in there. Didn't the parcel tax get approved? Thought small classroom sizes were from the parcel tax. Why are there 30 kids per classroom?


Palo Alto Res
Registered user
Downtown North
on Nov 22, 2021 at 6:30 am
Palo Alto Res, Downtown North
Registered user
on Nov 22, 2021 at 6:30 am

Statistics is a funny thing. Take for instance reading the numbers of percentage drop of PAUSD and Los Altos Schools. PAUSD is almost 3x the size of Los Altos, so 100 students leaving PAUSD versus Los Altos Schools will have a smaller percentage drop in PAUSD compared to Los Altos. It's quite unfair to compare the 2 schools as a percentage.

Also unfair that Bullis Charter School is not included in the Los Altos School given Bullis is part of Los Altos School District. That also skews Los Altos numbers, statistically speaking to be unfavorable for Los Altos.

Overall PAUSD should have the lowest percentage drop given it's the largest district in the all the schools listed. What would have been more comparable is if PAUSD was compared to Los Altos + Bullis + MVLA (combined). Instead, we see the numbers of PAUSD compared to everyone else and reading just the percentage unenrolled numbers, would obviously give lower percentages for PAUSD, which would belie the truth of the matter, which is PAUSD parents were very upset PAUSD could not keep up with the surrounding neighboring district schools in 2020 when the pandemic closed down the schools.

PAUSD took so much longer than their neighboring schools to get going, that PAUSD parents were fuming angry. While PAUSD parents begged Don Austin for online learning to begin, Los Altos parents were demanding synchronous online teaching replace their asynchronous online teaching.

Let's not compare apples to oranges with percentage numbers and assume PAUSD came out better as a leader. They did not. Absolutely they did not. They were followers in the pandemic.


Samuel L
Registered user
Meadow Park
on Nov 22, 2021 at 11:24 am
Samuel L, Meadow Park
Registered user
on Nov 22, 2021 at 11:24 am

PAUSD would rather have fewer students. They still get the property tax dollars. They'll always find a reason to keep as many teachers as possible and definitely all the administrators. They will always find a reason for declining enrollment, or anything that might put them in a negative light. As long as they can keep the PR machine running so that property values continue to grow, they don't really care about enrollment numbers. Having said that, the more students they can cram into a school, the more money they save and can spend on administrators. But, their goal is not efficiency.


Citizen
Registered user
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Nov 23, 2021 at 9:36 am
Citizen, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
Registered user
on Nov 23, 2021 at 9:36 am

Private school enrollments are up but the article doesn’t say they absorbed the decline. All it tells you is private schools did something some people who left publics wanted.

It doesn’t tell you anything about how many, where, and why the MAJORITY of people who left public schools went. Did they leave the area? Did they file PSAs and homeschool? The state doesn’t publish data on PSAs with <6 enrolled, but local districts have those numbers.

If private schools have 10% of students vs. public schools, +30% only accounts for 3% of public school losses, ie, if a public school has 1000 students and private has 100, and the public school loses 30% or 300, that’s not absorbed by +30% or 30 students at the private school. 90% who left are still unaccounted for.

That’s assuming increased APPLICATIONS (all the article discusses) to privates translate 100% to increased enrollment which we know isn’t so.

Where did families go?

A glaring reason is declining quality of life. This area has been ungodly expensive for decades, but we still had families. Yuppies arriving in the 80s who hated yards bought up all the $$$houses in Los Altos when they grew up. But more recent assaults on single family homes has meant any disruption (of many that density makes us vulnerable to) means people leave the area to get those homes.

The pandemic accelerated a trend caused by tech worker dormitization of local housing and attendant decimation of QoL in the false name of creating “affordability”. This works against families:
Web Link
Paraphrasing, SF Planning Dept report said the bldg boom there—mostly small apts—was unlikely to bring more families. For every 100 apts sold at market rates, the SF school district expects to enroll only ONE additional student.

Bottom line: Families want space and will leave to get it. The pandemic gave the push. How many? How many stayed but filed PSAs?


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Post a comment

In order to encourage respectful and thoughtful discussion, commenting on stories is available to those who are registered users. If you are already a registered user and the commenting form is not below, you need to log in. If you are not registered, you can do so here.

Please make sure your comments are truthful, on-topic and do not disrespect another poster. Don't be snarky or belittling. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

See our announcement about requiring registration for commenting.