News

Ravenswood leadership proposes closing Brentwood, Willow Oaks elementary schools

School board to discuss school mergers at special meeting this Friday, Dec. 6

The Ravenswood City School District has announced which of its five elementary schools have been proposed for closure next fall: Brentwood Academy in East Palo Alto and Willow Oaks Elementary School in Menlo Park.

Interim Superintendent Gina Sudaria is recommending that Brentwood students move to Costaño School in East Palo Alto and Willow Oaks students to Belle Haven Elementary School in Menlo Park. (See a map of the recommended changes here.)

On Wednesday, Sudaria notified the Board of Education, teachers and staff, and parents received a pre-recorded phone message from her in English and Spanish. The proposals are not final and are subject to approval by the school board.

Ravenswood began discussing school closures in earnest this summer, under new leadership and with a looming budget deficit. The K-8 district is aiming to cut $1.35 million from next year's budget. Closing a single school would save Ravenswood about $400,000.

Sudaria has said that merging schools is necessary for the survival of the district, where enrollment and corresponding state funding have been steadily declining for years. All of Ravenswood's elementary schools are operating at close to half capacity this year, and the district's overall enrollment is just over 2,000 students.

What's local journalism worth to you?

Support Palo Alto Online for as little as $5/month.

Learn more

Brentwood, the largest of the five elementary schools this year, with 330 students, also needs the most renovations, according to a presentation Sudaria will give to the school board at a special meeting on Friday.

In an interview Wednesday evening, Sudaria said that she and her leadership team took into consideration four priorities identified by community members and board members through an input-gathering process in recent weeks: location of schools, including keeping neighborhood schools and ensuring the three remaining schools are spread out so more students have a school nearby; minimizing the number of students impacted; considering the facility's size and condition; and protecting special programs such as dual-immersion, arts and mental health support.

They considered 12 merger scenarios, Sudaria said, and weighed each against additional factors, such as whether each school has enough students to be sustainable in the long term, the school's performance and whether closing a school would disproportionately affect any specific ethnic subgroup.

"I pride ourselves on having a team of diverse perspectives and points of view that pushed and challenged each other," Sudaria said. "There's not going to be 100% agreement, but at least there will be consensus and understanding of how we came to the proposal to the point where I'm confident that we've been able to weigh all the tradeoffs. I'm able to stand behind this proposal."

Under the recommendation, the district's dual-immersion program remains at Los Robles-Ronald McNair Academy (which is also the district's most recently renovated elementary school) and Turnaround Arts will stay at Costaño School. All three of the remaining elementary schools will keep their existing makerspaces, music and art offerings and school-based mental health services.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox.

Sign up

Other advantages to this consolidation plan are that Ravenswood can keep a school in Menlo Park, avoid further disruption for Los Robles students (who recently moved to McNair), minimize the use of portable buildings and ensure there are enough classrooms for all projected students, with room to grow in the future, according to the board presentation.

One downside is that Willow Oaks students will have to take a bus to Belle Haven; however, more Willow Oaks students already ride a bus — 175 — than at other schools, according to the district. And while Brentwood students will have to move schools, they already are more spread throughout the district than other elementary students.

If the board approves this plan, starting next fall, current Brentwood kindergarten through fourth grade students would attend Costaño; current Willow Oaks kindergarten through fourth grade students would go to Belle Haven; and Los Robles-McNair, Belle Haven and Costaño students would stay at their current schools.

Brentwood and Willow Oaks families would be able to choose to enroll at a different school if they wish, and students at other schools can choose to transfer after Brentwood and Willow Oaks students are accommodated. The district would provide buses if needed for students to attend their new schools.

Middle schoolers will be unaffected by the mergers.

Any students who are new to the district next fall will be able to choose which elementary school to attend.

Staff at the affected schools will generally move with students, though principals, office staff and potentially custodians will be cut, according to the proposal. Classified staff who would be affected would be notified in February.

Ravenswood doesn't plan to layoff any teachers, Sudaria wrote in her presentation; any cuts will be covered by natural attrition.

The district plans to explore leasing out the Brentwood and Willow Oaks campuses to bring in additional revenue, Sudaria said, and to address a likely expansion request from Kipp charter school in East Palo Alto.

"In order for this district to continue to thrive and renew itself we have to be optimistic in the possibilities," Sudaria said. "On the other side of this is going to be stronger school communities and programs for students."

Sudaria is encouraging community members to share their feedback on the merger plan at several upcoming public meetings.

"There might be other scenarios or reasons for another scenario that we have not considered," she said.

On Thursday, Dec. 5, Ravenswood's District Advisory Council (DAC) and District English Learner Advisory Council (DELAC) will hear the proposal from Sudaria. Child care, food and translation will be provided. The meeting will be at 6 p.m. at the district office, 2120 Euclid Ave., East Palo Alto.

The school board will discuss the mergers on Friday, Dec. 6, at 7:15 p.m. (view the agenda here) and at its regular meeting next Thursday, Dec. 12, both held at the district office.

The board is set to make a final decision on which schools to close on Jan. 9.

There will also be informational meetings at each elementary school on the following dates:

- Willow Oaks: Dec. 9 at 6 p.m.

- Brentwood Academy: Dec. 10 at 6 p.m.

- Los Robles Ronald McNair Dual Immersion: Dec. 11 at 6 p.m.

- Belle Haven School: Dec. 16 at 6 p.m.

- Costaño School: Dec. 17 at 6 p.m.

Information about the mergers and an opportunity to provide input online are available at ravenswoodschools.net/school-mergers.

Craving a new voice in Peninsula dining?

Sign up for the Peninsula Foodist newsletter.

Sign up now

Follow Palo Alto Online and the Palo Alto Weekly on Twitter @paloaltoweekly, Facebook and on Instagram @paloaltoonline for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Ravenswood leadership proposes closing Brentwood, Willow Oaks elementary schools

School board to discuss school mergers at special meeting this Friday, Dec. 6

by / Palo Alto Weekly

Uploaded: Wed, Dec 4, 2019, 10:59 pm

The Ravenswood City School District has announced which of its five elementary schools have been proposed for closure next fall: Brentwood Academy in East Palo Alto and Willow Oaks Elementary School in Menlo Park.

Interim Superintendent Gina Sudaria is recommending that Brentwood students move to Costaño School in East Palo Alto and Willow Oaks students to Belle Haven Elementary School in Menlo Park. (See a map of the recommended changes here.)

On Wednesday, Sudaria notified the Board of Education, teachers and staff, and parents received a pre-recorded phone message from her in English and Spanish. The proposals are not final and are subject to approval by the school board.

Ravenswood began discussing school closures in earnest this summer, under new leadership and with a looming budget deficit. The K-8 district is aiming to cut $1.35 million from next year's budget. Closing a single school would save Ravenswood about $400,000.

Sudaria has said that merging schools is necessary for the survival of the district, where enrollment and corresponding state funding have been steadily declining for years. All of Ravenswood's elementary schools are operating at close to half capacity this year, and the district's overall enrollment is just over 2,000 students.

Brentwood, the largest of the five elementary schools this year, with 330 students, also needs the most renovations, according to a presentation Sudaria will give to the school board at a special meeting on Friday.

In an interview Wednesday evening, Sudaria said that she and her leadership team took into consideration four priorities identified by community members and board members through an input-gathering process in recent weeks: location of schools, including keeping neighborhood schools and ensuring the three remaining schools are spread out so more students have a school nearby; minimizing the number of students impacted; considering the facility's size and condition; and protecting special programs such as dual-immersion, arts and mental health support.

They considered 12 merger scenarios, Sudaria said, and weighed each against additional factors, such as whether each school has enough students to be sustainable in the long term, the school's performance and whether closing a school would disproportionately affect any specific ethnic subgroup.

"I pride ourselves on having a team of diverse perspectives and points of view that pushed and challenged each other," Sudaria said. "There's not going to be 100% agreement, but at least there will be consensus and understanding of how we came to the proposal to the point where I'm confident that we've been able to weigh all the tradeoffs. I'm able to stand behind this proposal."

Under the recommendation, the district's dual-immersion program remains at Los Robles-Ronald McNair Academy (which is also the district's most recently renovated elementary school) and Turnaround Arts will stay at Costaño School. All three of the remaining elementary schools will keep their existing makerspaces, music and art offerings and school-based mental health services.

Other advantages to this consolidation plan are that Ravenswood can keep a school in Menlo Park, avoid further disruption for Los Robles students (who recently moved to McNair), minimize the use of portable buildings and ensure there are enough classrooms for all projected students, with room to grow in the future, according to the board presentation.

One downside is that Willow Oaks students will have to take a bus to Belle Haven; however, more Willow Oaks students already ride a bus — 175 — than at other schools, according to the district. And while Brentwood students will have to move schools, they already are more spread throughout the district than other elementary students.

If the board approves this plan, starting next fall, current Brentwood kindergarten through fourth grade students would attend Costaño; current Willow Oaks kindergarten through fourth grade students would go to Belle Haven; and Los Robles-McNair, Belle Haven and Costaño students would stay at their current schools.

Brentwood and Willow Oaks families would be able to choose to enroll at a different school if they wish, and students at other schools can choose to transfer after Brentwood and Willow Oaks students are accommodated. The district would provide buses if needed for students to attend their new schools.

Middle schoolers will be unaffected by the mergers.

Any students who are new to the district next fall will be able to choose which elementary school to attend.

Staff at the affected schools will generally move with students, though principals, office staff and potentially custodians will be cut, according to the proposal. Classified staff who would be affected would be notified in February.

Ravenswood doesn't plan to layoff any teachers, Sudaria wrote in her presentation; any cuts will be covered by natural attrition.

The district plans to explore leasing out the Brentwood and Willow Oaks campuses to bring in additional revenue, Sudaria said, and to address a likely expansion request from Kipp charter school in East Palo Alto.

"In order for this district to continue to thrive and renew itself we have to be optimistic in the possibilities," Sudaria said. "On the other side of this is going to be stronger school communities and programs for students."

Sudaria is encouraging community members to share their feedback on the merger plan at several upcoming public meetings.

"There might be other scenarios or reasons for another scenario that we have not considered," she said.

On Thursday, Dec. 5, Ravenswood's District Advisory Council (DAC) and District English Learner Advisory Council (DELAC) will hear the proposal from Sudaria. Child care, food and translation will be provided. The meeting will be at 6 p.m. at the district office, 2120 Euclid Ave., East Palo Alto.

The school board will discuss the mergers on Friday, Dec. 6, at 7:15 p.m. (view the agenda here) and at its regular meeting next Thursday, Dec. 12, both held at the district office.

The board is set to make a final decision on which schools to close on Jan. 9.

There will also be informational meetings at each elementary school on the following dates:

- Willow Oaks: Dec. 9 at 6 p.m.

- Brentwood Academy: Dec. 10 at 6 p.m.

- Los Robles Ronald McNair Dual Immersion: Dec. 11 at 6 p.m.

- Belle Haven School: Dec. 16 at 6 p.m.

- Costaño School: Dec. 17 at 6 p.m.

Information about the mergers and an opportunity to provide input online are available at ravenswoodschools.net/school-mergers.

Comments

Marrol
Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
on Dec 5, 2019 at 10:47 am
Marrol, Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
on Dec 5, 2019 at 10:47 am
19 people like this

And yet it was just a few months ago that the same school board was fretting and spinning their wheels over the relevance of name changes. These are the results of an organization more concerned about symbolism over substance.


Anon
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Dec 5, 2019 at 2:57 pm
Anon, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Dec 5, 2019 at 2:57 pm
5 people like this

The problem with closing Willow Oaks is the severe bottleneck getting across 101.


revdreileen
Registered user
East Palo Alto
on Dec 5, 2019 at 3:24 pm
revdreileen, East Palo Alto
Registered user
on Dec 5, 2019 at 3:24 pm
9 people like this

The effects of closing both of these schools will impact students who live west of 101 the most. Closing one or the other makes sense, but not both of them. The children in my neighborhood will have have to go to school very far from home.


Mark Dinan
Registered user
East Palo Alto
on Dec 5, 2019 at 4:28 pm
Mark Dinan, East Palo Alto
Registered user
on Dec 5, 2019 at 4:28 pm
9 people like this

These are tough decisions driven by declining enrollment due to Charter Schools, Tinsley, and The Primary School. The teachers union, the acting superintendent, and the school board seem to be aligned on this plan, and undoubtedly hate having to close schools to save money. "Ripping off the bandaid" and tackling this head on to address the huge deficit is the right thing to do. I commend the leaders who are driving this process. While it is tough news to absorb, keeping half empty schools open is a very bad financial proposition.


Miguel
East Palo Alto
on Dec 5, 2019 at 5:21 pm
Miguel, East Palo Alto
on Dec 5, 2019 at 5:21 pm
6 people like this

Commend all involved for stepping up and recommending to the Board to contract both at once rather than one at a time. NEVER announce to a bargaining unit, certificated employees, that they’ll be no layoffs and only rely on attrition. Notice the appropriate number of certificated, I.e. worst case, by March 15th. Don’t create a classified vs. certificated comparison needlessly.


SAD
East Palo Alto
on Dec 5, 2019 at 9:03 pm
SAD, East Palo Alto
on Dec 5, 2019 at 9:03 pm
2 people like this

This is a sign that the district will no londer exist 10 years from now. .


Anon
Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Dec 6, 2019 at 1:38 pm
Anon, Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Dec 6, 2019 at 1:38 pm
Like this comment

Posted by SAD, a resident of East Palo Alto

>> This is a sign that the district will no londer exist 10 years from now. .

Why? Is the entire district being converted to office parks? More generally-- is there a link to a webpage that explains why the school age population has declined so drastically in the district?


Willows Resident
Menlo Park
on Dec 9, 2019 at 9:58 pm
Willows Resident , Menlo Park
on Dec 9, 2019 at 9:58 pm
1 person likes this

I find that the leadership still does not get it. Why close the only school West of 101 (Willow Oaks) where I would have to assume a large group of students/families live. There is no safe route to walk or bike to the other campuses which causes more congestion. Yes, there be busses, but that doesn’t always work for students who have different schedules.

How strange that the OConnor Street petition brought the proximity to schools as a valid argument on why they wanted to attend MPSD and now the only school in RSD in the Willows is closing down and the next nearest one is closing as well which strengthens the rationale of this group as people want to go school in their neighborhoods and not be biased for 45 minutes to schools across the freeway.


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.