Real Estate

Local garden club aims to create safe havens for monarchs

Also, five ways to attract butterflies to your gardens

It's a startling statistic: The California monarch butterfly population has dropped 86 percent since last year. This was the information provided last month by the Xerces Society, a science-based organization focusing on the conservation, protection and restoration of invertebrate habitats. During the society's annual Western Monarch Thanksgiving count, it was reported there were only 28,429 monarchs in the state.

The count, which was completed in November 2018, had approximately 100 volunteers counting monarchs across 213 sites throughout California. Although some of the loss in butterfly numbers may be attributed to massive wildfires throughout the state last year and climate change affecting the world, the truth is that the monarch butterfly population has been steadily declining since the 1990s.

"In the '90s, a lot of scientists and lovers of monarchs realized the numbers were down, so there has been an effort for the last 25 years to tag the monarchs, try to figure out where they're going, try to get everybody to plant milkweed and track migrations," said Palo Alto Garden Club Conservation member Eleanor Laney, who is one of the leaders of the garden club's Monarch Butterfly Project. The project encourages residents to create butterfly-friendly gardens. Last year, the project successfully released 100 monarchs, which may not seem like a lot, but Laney said that butterfly eggs are "considered caviar" to other insects and only one of every 100 eggs completes its growth cycle to become a butterfly.

Another person doing her part to protect monarch populations is landscape designer Rebecca Schoenenberger, who owns California Nativescapes. As a UC master gardener, Schoenenberger said that there's still much to learn about the monarch butterfly population, and although scientists are still studying this much-loved insect, the decline in population is alarming.

"There are a lot of things we don't know about monarchs," she said. "What we do know is that population counts have dropped dramatically over the last couple of years. There's not really specific evidence pointing to any single factor. It's probably multiple factors as to why that's happening, including pesticide use and habitat loss and destruction. Only certain habitats are protected and there are only a handful of those in California."

There also has been a slight surge in recent years of homeowners installing non-insect-friendly landscapes, which eliminates a food source for monarch butterflies. Another problem, Laney said, is the use of pesticides, particularly those with glyphosate, which kills milkweed plants.

"The problem now is the only thing that the monarch will lay her eggs on is milkweed," said Laney. "If there's no milkweed, there are no monarchs."

To increase the amount of milkweed in people's yards, the Monarch Butterfly Project encourages Palo Alto Garden Club members and their neighbors to plant native milkweed (as opposed to the tropical type) in their gardens in an effort to create a birthing center for monarchs, who die after laying their eggs, and a food source for caterpillars after they hatch.

Both Schoenenberger and Laney are adamant about the need to plant the right kind of milkweed, the native form, rather than non-native strains found in some nurseries, which are toxic to monarchs.

"A big problem is the tropical milkweed," said Schoenenberger. "It's usually what's available at the nursery and often from Mexico. It doesn't go dormant in the winter and will build up a parasite that is deadly to monarchs. It's like junk food or drugs. It builds up with this parasite and the parasite hosts inside the monarch when it's a larvae. It prevents the monarch from growing."

Laney said the tropical milkweed has pretty orange and yellow flowers.

"People love it," she said. "And, the monarchs love it" even though its not good for them.

Laney encourages those who want to plant tropical milkweed to cut it back throughout the winter.

"That way you have cut off all of the potentially infected leaves," she said.

Another important part of a butterfly-friendly landscape are nectar plants, which provide food and energy when monarchs emerge from their cocoons and prepare to continue on their journey north. Ideally, these plants also will be California natives.

"A garden that supports monarchs has nectar plants and native milkweed plants and a couple of types of milkweed," said Laney.

"Milkweed is a nursery plant for the monarch," said Schoenenberger. "It provides food for the caterpillars, and flowers provide food for the butterflies. The numbers are telling us we're at a critical point with the monarchs and our numbers are telling us that we have to do something."

Melissa McKenzie is a freelance writer for the Weekly. She can be emailed at

Five ways to attract butterflies to your garden

1 Select your native milkweed. According to the Xerces Society, California native milkweeds include California milkweed (asclepias californica), purple milkweed/heartleaf milkweed (asclepias cordifolia), woollypod milkweed/Indian milkweed (asclepias eriocarpa), narrow-leaved milkweed (asclepias fascicularis), showy milkweed (asclepias speciosa)

2 Plant your milkweed, which is drought tolerant and requires minimal care, in the sun and near nectar plants. Laney believes a minimalist butterfly nursery should contain a minimum of three native milkweed plants and two pollinating plants.

3 When choosing your nectar, Laney recommends the following plants: verbena, clarkia, yarrow, tithonia, California buckwheat and woolly sunflower. Schoenenberger said she keeps zinnias and dahlias in her summer garden because they're big, bright flowers for butterflies to land on.

4 Get your neighbors to plant butterfly-friendly habitat plants to give migrating monarchs more options.

5 Do not use any pesticides, as even organic pesticides can be fatal to butterfly colonies.

What is community worth to you?
Support local journalism.


Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Stay informed

Get daily headlines sent straight to your inbox.

Legends Pizza Co. replaces Palo Alto Pizza Co.
By Elena Kadvany | 10 comments | 2,623 views

Premarital and Couples: 10 Tips for the Holidays
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 2,352 views

What is a "ton" of carbon dioxide anyway?
By Sherry Listgarten | 13 comments | 2,246 views

Do city officials ever consider giving taxpayers a break?
By Diana Diamond | 18 comments | 1,159 views

By Cheryl Bac | 0 comments | 975 views


Palo Alto Weekly Holiday Fund

For the last 26 years, the Palo Alto Weekly Holiday Fund has given away more than $7 million to local nonprofits serving children and families. When you make a donation, every dollar is automatically doubled, and 100% of the funds go directly to local programs. It’s a great way to ensure your charitable donations are working at home.