Izzy Ditzler took a long pass in front of the goal, pumped-faked a couple of times and then skipped a shot into the right corner of the net to end a six-overtime girls water polo match Wednesday night.
The sudden death goal, coming with less than 10 seconds remaining in the overtime period, gave St. Francis an 8-7 victory over visiting Sacred Heart Prep in a battle for first place in the West Catholic Athletic League.
Sacred Heart Prep coach Jon Burke called the game, which lasted two hours, "one for the ages."
The Lancers (9-5, 4-0) ended SH Prep's 20-match WCAL regular-season winning streak, which dates to Oct. 23, 2013, when the Lancers also beat the Gators (11-5, 3-1).
Sacred Heart Prep, the 10-time defending CCS Division II champion, still owns an overall WCAL record of 63-4.
St. Francis played from behind until Ditzler's goal ended it. Lancers' Izzy Mandema, who attended St. Raymond's in Menlo Park, scored twice in the second quarter to knot the game at 3 entering halftime.
The Gators took a 6-4 edge into the fourth quarter, when Mandema scored twice again to force a mandatory two-period overtime.
SH Prep led, 7-6, after the first overtime and was within a minute of winning. Mandema's tying goal sent the match into sudden death, which is divided into three-minute periods until someone scores.
It was a classic game full of highlight-reel plays and saves. SHP's Nellie McAdams (11 saves) and SF's Natalie Blanc stood strong in the net for both sides.
Annabel Facey led the Gators with three goals. Addi Duvall and Nadia Paquin each added a pair.
The Gators had a defender in front of the cage with McAdams but Ditzler wasn't challenged right away, giving her the scoring opportunity.
St. Francis and Sacred Heart Prep, which have split two games thus far this season, are almost assured of meeting again in the WCAL tournament and possibly in the CCS Open Division.
The Lancers are competing in an event at Menlo-Atherton, with St. Francis playing Las Lomas at 2:30 p.m. and College Park at 4:30 p.m.
Sacred Heart Prep hosts Menlo School at 6 p.m. Tuesday in a nonleague affair.
Meanwhile, Castilleja remains in charge of the PAL Bay Division race after beating Menlo, 11-6, on Wednesday.
The Gators (11-3, 5-0) have two league matches remaining and are seeking to repeat as unbeaten league champions. Castilleja won its first-ever league title in 2014.
Madison Lewis recorded four goals and seven steals to lead Castilleja, which competes in the Clovis Tournament beginning Friday.
Minhee Chung added five goals and Anjali Kambham contributed two steals and solid defense in front of goalie Georgia Lewis, who had eight saves.
Gillian Bressie also had eight saves for Menlo, which travels to Sacred Heart Prep for a nonleague match at 6 p.m. Tuesday.
Boys water polo
Scared Heart Prep came within 1:08 of a shutout Wednesday, beating host St. Francis 12-1 in a West Catholic Athletic League contest.
Gators goalie Alexander Nemeth turned away all but one of 15 shots on net and had a team-high three steals.
SH Prep (8-2, 5-0) scored the game's first 12 goals before Berk Aksoy spoiled the party. He found the back of the net with 1:08 remaining to play.
Larsen Weigle and Alex Tsotadze each scored four goals for the Gators, who clinched at least a tie for the WCAL title. SHP has a bye next week and finishes with Mitty (6-12, 0-4) in two weeks. The Gators are a game up on Bellarmine and beat the Bells earlier in the year.
Sacred Heart Prep is scheduled to compete in the S&R Tourney at UC Irvine beginning Friday. The Gators went 3-1 in last year's event and finished third.
In the PAL Bay Division, Giorgio Fatica scored nine goals to lead Woodside past visiting Carlmont, 15-7 on Wednesday.
The Wildcats (7-7, 2-2) led 7-5 at halftime and then outscored the Scots, 7-0, in the third quarter to take control of the contest.
Cameron Vaughan added four goals for Woodside, which meets Aptos in the first round of the Aptos Tournament on Friday.
Woodside meets PAL leader Menlo next Wednesday.
Menlo-Atherton and Burlingame were also scheduled to play Wednesday.
Menlo won its third West Bay Athletic League contest in as many days, beating host Notre Dame-San Jose, 217-260, on Wednesday.
The Knights (9-1 overall) actually have a game lead over Castilleja and Harker, both at 7-1 overall, and play Castilleja twice in the next two weeks, beginning with a match at Menlo CC on Monday.
Sophomore Vikki Xu birdied the first hole and never let up, earning medalist honors with a solid 38. Xu added five pars. Sophomore Gianna Inguagiato birdied No. 8 to finish with a 39.
Another sophomore Sulwen Ma, whose round featured several good tee shots, had five pars as she shot a 40.
Sophomore Kendall Weingart shot a 54 in her first official match of the season. Freshman Sarah Fujimori fired a season-best 46, with three pars.
"She hit the ball extremely well throughout her round," Menlo coach Jim Miller said.
In the SCVAL, Palo Alto (10-0) beat Los Gatos, 192-222.
Addie Ahlstrom, Lindsey Ball and Elika Eshghi each won their singles matches to lead hist Menlo School past Menlo-Atherton, 6-1, in a nonleague match Wednesday.
The doubles team of Charlotte Lee and Penelope Anderson turned a tie-breaker victory to help the Knights (8-6), who host Harker in a WBAL Foothill Division match at 3:30 p.m. Thursday.
The Bears (10-5) were without top singles player Lanie Van Linge but No. 2 Julia Marks responded with a tie-breaker win over Menlo's No. 1 Taylor Gould, who just returned from an ankle injury.
M-A travels to Burlingame for a PAL match Thursday at 4 p.m.