News

Following Turner's release, recall-campaign organizers rally

Stanford students, Palo Alto mayor speak out against Judge Aaron Persky

Local and national elected officials, Stanford University students, sexual-assault survivors, parents and others threw their support behind the official campaign to recall Santa Clara County Judge Aaron Persky on Friday morning, speaking at a rally held across the jail from where Brock Turner had been released just hours before.

The Recall Persky campaign, led by Stanford law professor and Palo Alto resident Michele Dauber, organized a lineup of 14 speakers who, one by one, said that Persky has proved himself unfit to remain on the bench. Standing in front of a large group of solemn protesters holding signs with messages like "don't legalize rape" and "hold Persky accountable," they spoke about the broader implications they believe Persky's record holds for the legal system and for victims of sexual violence.

"Women have a fundamental right to expect fairness and justice from the courts of law," Dauber told the crowd in her opening remarks, citing several recently publicized cases overseen by Persky that she says prove a longstanding pattern of his bias toward privileged and white defendants.

"Judicial independence is important, but it depends on a lack of bias. There is no independence where there is bias. Judge Persky's bias is a threat to the rule of law," she continued, "and we will continue until he is no longer a judge."

Several elected officials, including Palo Alto Mayor Pat Burt, called for Persky's resignation on Friday.

"I call on not only Judge Persky to resign but for his colleagues on the bench to stand up for integrity that they know is right and not hide behind a claim of judicial independence when they know that judicial independence is undermined by the judicial bias that Judge Persky has presented," Burt told the crowd.

Two survivors of sexual violence also spoke on Friday: Kamilah Willingham, a Harvard Law School graduate whose story was featured in The Hunting Ground, a documentary about sexual assault on college campuses; and Sofie Karasek, an activist and one of several University of California, Berkeley students who filed a Title IX complaint against the university with the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights.

The two women detailed their assaults and the unsatisfying criminal and administrative processes they endured afterwards — processes that Willingham said for many victims can feel like a "second rape."

And Willingham and Karasek, as outspoken activists who reported their assaults, are not the norm, they noted. Most victims are unwilling to report their assaults to their universities or local law enforcement. Persky's six-month jail sentence for Turner, who was found guilty of three sexual-assault felony charges, has only made it less likely that victims will report these crimes, the women said.

“If judges valued survivors more, maybe the Brock Turners of the world would as well," Willingham said.

Stephanie Pham, a rising Stanford junior and co-founder of the university's Association of Students for Sexual Assault Prevention, further criticized Persky: "Instead of upholding fairness, accountability and equal justice, Judge Persky decided to excuse Brock Turner of sexual violence, inevitably undermining trust in the legal system at large, diminishing reporting of assaults and making the Stanford community a more dangerous place for all."

The other speakers included Senate Pro Tem Kevin De Leon, Rep. Eric Swalwell, Rep. Jerry McNerney, Rep. Loretta Sanchez, State Senator Jim Beall, Assemblymember Nora Campos, Congressional candidate Ro Khanna, former Milpitas mayor Bob Linvegood and California NOW President Jerilyn Stapleton.

De Leon spoke to the men in the crowd, telling them that sexual assault "is a man's issue as well."

"That's why it's important that fathers, boyfriends, members of Congress and Senate and legislature, mayors and city councils and brothers and cousins and uncles and grandfathers; straight, LGBTQ, Latino, African-American, white, racially mixed, Asian-American -- all men should rise together in solidarity" with women, De Leon said.

A mother in the crowd, Jessica Williams, agreed. She brought with her a handmade sign that read "don't get raped," with the "get" and "d" in "raped" crossed out to read "don't rape."

"The message that women get is, 'dress appropriately so you don't get raped; don't drink too much so you don't get raped,'" the 35-year-old mother of three daughters said in an interview with the Weekly. "I think the message should be instead to men, 'Don't rape.' I think we need to switch the focus."

Others in attendance on Friday included Ben Taylor, a Stanford student who felt compelled to come because he has three sisters, and Stella Xu, a local high school student who skipped school just to attend the rally.

"That's how important it was to me," said 17-year-old Xu, holding a sign that read "justice for survivors."

She said she came to stand in solidarity with survivors of sexual violence and with the recall effort.

"People say we can't go back and retry Turner and that's true, but we can still prevent future instances like this and show other judges that giving lenient rulings isn't OK by recalling the judge," Xu said.

The recall campaign has raised more than $250,000 so far but has a long way to go to gather the number of signatures required to mount a special election in November 2017.

Meanwhile, Persky has started gathering support for an anti-recall campaign, launched earlier this week. He has also voluntarily withdrawn from hearing criminal cases and will be reassigned to civil matters at the San Jose courthouse starting this Tuesday.

In a statement posted on the "Retain Judge Persky" campaign website, Persky wrote: "I believe strongly in judicial independence. I took an oath to uphold the Constitution, not to appease politicians or ideologues. When your own rights and property are at stake, you want the judge to make a fair and lawful decision, free from political influence."

The website includes links to statements from supporters and those who have spoken out publicly in defense of judicial independence, including a group of retired Santa Clara County Superior Court judges[, the Santa Clara County Bar Association, the California Judges Association and retired Stanford law professor Barbara Babcock.

One of the retired judges, LaDoris Cordell, who has publicly said she disagrees with the Turner sentence, wrote in an email to the Weekly Tuesday that she nonetheless opposes the recall. She called it an "abuse of the recall process" and a threat to judicial independence.

"If it succeeds, then judges will be looking over their shoulders before making any sentencing decisions, for fear of being targeted by someone who doesn't like their rulings," Cordell said. "I believe that the recall process should be utilized to remove judges who have a demonstrated record of abusing and/or misusing their authority or who have a history of making unlawful or biased decisions. Judge Persky does not have such a record."

The Palo Alto Weekly has created Storify pages to capture ongoing coverage of the Brock Turner case as well as sexual-assault issues at Stanford University. To view them, go to storify.com/paloaltoweekly.

---

Follow the Palo Alto Weekly/Palo Alto Online on Twitter @PaloAltoWeekly and Facebook for breaking news, local events, photos, videos and more.

Comments

Like this comment
Posted by Peña Nieto
a resident of College Terrace
on Sep 2, 2016 at 4:06 pm

[Post removed.]


18 people like this
Posted by End Judicial Bias Against Women
a resident of Barron Park
on Sep 3, 2016 at 9:29 am

End Judicial Bias Against Women is a registered user.

LaDoris Cordell also publicly said that the Ikaika Gunderson case of the football player from Foothill who Persky sent to Hawaii for a year without even putting him on probation after he savagely beat his girlfriend was so mishandled by Persky that "it was hard to even know where to start" saying what was wrong with it.

Cordell is erratic and talks out of both sides of her mouth.

These judges need to decide if they are going to continue to stand with Persky and his consistent bias against women, or with the people. You can't hide behind judicial independence when you are dealing with such flagrant bias against women and in favor of privileged college athletes who abuse women.

As Mayor Burt said in his eloquent remarks yesterday the victim of this case is one of the daughters of our own Palo Alto community and the graduate of our schools. GET WITH THE PROGRAM, judges and lawyers. Remember your community and the people you serve, including the 50% who are female.


8 people like this
Posted by Ze'ev Wurman
a resident of Palo Verde
on Sep 3, 2016 at 12:33 pm

Michelle Dauber: "Women have a fundamental right to expect fairness and justice from the courts of law."

Indeed, they do. But so do men. Dauber continued:

"Judicial independence is important, but it depends on a lack of bias. There is no independence where there is bias. Judge Persky's bias is a threat to the rule of law."

I agree ... except for the last clause. Yet despite all her efforts to uncover bias in Persky's thousands cases over his decade and half on the bench, all Prof. Dauber has to show is the Brock Turner's case where Persky followed the guidance of the Probation Officer, and a 2011 case when the jury -- not the judge -- found defendants in a rape case not guilty. Persky was "accused" that he allowed evidence into the process that Prof. Dauber thinks he should not have. Well, that's why we have judges, rather than rabble-rousing politicians and law professors, to rule on cases before them.

That's all the rabble-rousers found for Persky's 15 years on the bench. Or for the disingenuous accusations of bias supposedly because Turner was a Stanford student and Persky is an alumnus. The defendants in the 2011 case, however, were De Anza students. [Portion removed.]


Posted by police are rogue element
a resident of Palo Alto Hills

on Sep 3, 2016 at 2:58 pm


Remember me?
Forgot Password?
Due to violations of our Terms of Use, comments from this poster are only visible to registered users who are logged in. Use the links at the top of the page to Register or Login.


6 people like this
Posted by Palo Alto Resident
a resident of Old Palo Alto
on Sep 5, 2016 at 12:24 pm

Interested readers might want to watch a video of Friday's rally; it includes the entire program of speakers:

Web Link


Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

He said – she said – who is lying? Justice Brett Kavanaugh or PA resident Christine Ford
By Diana Diamond | 69 comments | 6,806 views

Let's Talk Internships
By John Raftrey and Lori McCormick | 1 comment | 1,068 views

Populism: A response to the failure of the elites: Palo Alto edition
By Douglas Moran | 1 comment | 996 views

Couples: Sex and Connection (Chicken or Egg?)
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 941 views

Zucchini Takeover
By Laura Stec | 1 comment | 827 views