Real Estate

Real Estate Matters

Are we heading toward a correction this year?

At the beginning of 2015, I wrote the column "A long-term cyclical view" and pointed out the high probability of a temporary correction in property pricing in Palo Alto, assuming everything is cyclical and looking back at the two price declines of the past 17 years.

The median home price in Palo Alto for all sold transactions in 2015 actually rose by another 14 percent to reach $2.485 million. This marked the fourth-consecutive year of double-digit increase, and contrary to my earlier projection, the "super cycle" seemed intact. A strong local tech economy, low inventory and multiple layers of demand were among many factors that continued to support property prices in Palo Alto.

What's the outlook for this year? Is the tide finally going to turn? I do see increasing probabilities that the market is going to change. Among various moving parts of the market, many are pointing to the same direction.

1. Local buyers have started to experience weakening purchasing power. The NASDAQ Composite Index closed 19 percent below its 2015 high on Jan. 22. This is definitely not encouraging for local buyers who plan to cash their stock options as an initial down payment. This trend has already emerged in South Bay where buyers backed off at the last minute to write offers. Weak tech-stock performance in general may be another reason why buyers have become more willing to wait. Since last summer, especially for entry level homes in Palo Alto, a high number of offers has become less likely to lift the final selling price as it used to in the past few years.

2. International demands may soften, too. While there's no reliable statistic to tell us the real impact of international, mainly Chinese, buyers on our property market, they do play a role that can't be ignored. The big correction of Shanghai Composite Index early this year (down 18 percent in the first three trading weeks this year) basically triggered the weakness of global stock markets. This brings a different impact for potential Chinese buyers. For high-end buyers ($4 million or more), the big decline of local stock market only reminded them how "safe" an investment the homes here in Palo Alto are and basically increased the attractiveness of Palo Alto property as an investment alternative. Many of them also have financial resources already in U.S. dollars that can be re-directed to buy homes here whenever they want. Consequently, demands this year may remain strong on high-end homes, especially in north Palo Alto.

However, for mid-to-low-end Chinese buyers, the weak stock market will put a more meaningful dent in their wealth portfolio. Moreover, cash-out refinancing is normally part of the game plan for buyers in this segment. It means that they buy homes in all cash but plan to borrow against the home later so that the funds can be put somewhere generating possibly higher return. One commonly used international bank has just restricted lending on home mortgages to foreign residents, including Chinese. Furthermore, many of the mid-to-low-end Chinese buyers need to convert Chinese currency to U.S. dollars to be able to participate in the property market here. Chinese RMB has never been a freely traded currency; it has just become more difficult due to both government controls and the market's fear of continuous RMB depreciation against U.S. dollar.

3. Potential sellers may become more willing to take actions now than later. For many local residents, short-term ups and downs of property price have little impact on their daily life. However, for people who are considering selling their homes within two to three years, they may start to accelerate the process once they see that bidding wars are cooling and buyers have become less desperate. In hindsight, once the market starts to correct, it normally takes about two years to recover. The fear of having missed the peak of the market (and for many sellers, it becomes a reality) could lead to more houses on the market. In addition to weakening demand, the increasing supply could soften the pace of price increase or might lead to a moderate price decline.

The market is constantly evolving. 2016 will definitely bring a tough test of the resilience of the property market in Palo Alto.

Xin Jiang is a Realtor with Alain Pinel Realtors in Palo Alto. She can be reached at xjiang@apr.com.

Comments

7 people like this
Posted by PA renter
a resident of Downtown North
on Feb 6, 2016 at 6:50 pm

interesting opinion piece


17 people like this
Posted by Long view
a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Feb 8, 2016 at 8:00 am

The world is only getting more crowded and this is a desirable place. Long term view, in order to stay, it's necessary to buy. I don't know why people complain that they can't afford to buy a house, they usually make more than we do, and could get a mortgage for half than when we got in. What they mean is, they aren't prepared to make the kind of extreme sacrifices we and most people we know who bought did, for years and years on end, in order to get into the market. What they mean is, they can't afford to buy something they would want to live in. Or they aren't prepared to do the work to get a loan from 20 rekatives instead, etc. i don't know anyone personally who waltzed in and bought a house, only heard stories.

The market does correct and things do temporarily go down. It is possible to lose money in the short-term. But all the things people are saying about how unaffordable it is now, are more of the same from the last boom. Often when things go down, mamy people are unwilling to sell so supply dries up even more. This is not a normal market.


15 people like this
Posted by Ask China
a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Feb 8, 2016 at 3:44 pm

There may be a correction, how big depends on how quickly and how harshly China acts.

Chinese banks are losing trillions of dollars every year, according to various financial publications, to investment in US, European, Canadian, other Asian, and Australian residential and business real estate. The borrowers who leave the country with millions of dollars in loan money never repay it, and never return to China.

China has already clamped down on loans to people deemed a flight risk. However, their threats of finding, prosecuting, and punishing in China these offenders has so far been toothless. No Chinese nationals have been extradited nor suddenly disappeared, to date.


9 people like this
Posted by Ask China
a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Feb 8, 2016 at 4:00 pm

I highly doubt that the US or Europe will cooperate with extradition requests from China, knowing full well that these fugitive borrowers would surely be sent to their deaths--by ha going, no less


Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Populism: A response to the failure of the elites: Palo Alto edition
By Douglas Moran | 7 comments | 1,347 views

Let's Talk Internships
By John Raftrey and Lori McCormick | 1 comment | 1,341 views

Couples: Sex and Connection (Chicken or Egg?)
By Chandrama Anderson | 1 comment | 1,063 views

Zucchini Takeover
By Laura Stec | 2 comments | 878 views

Mountain View's Hangen Szechuan to close after 25 years
By Elena Kadvany | 0 comments | 485 views