City, school district reach breakthrough on Cubberley

Palo Alto council, school board set to sign off on a new deal next week

After two years of uncertainty, the City of Palo Alto and the Palo Alto Unified School District have reached a breakthrough on new lease terms for the Cubberlely Community Center, the sprawling campus whose future has been in limbo while the deal was being hashed out.

The terms of the new agreement, which school district Superintendent Max McGee announced at a special meeting Wednesday morning, are scheduled to be ratified by the City Council on Nov. 17 and by the district's Board of Education on Nov. 18. The current lease was set to expire at the end of December.

At Wednesday's meeting, school trustees indicated that they will support the terms, which include the scrapping of the controversial "covenant not to develop" in the existing agreement.

The long-standing covenant has been the main sticking point in negotiations. Adopted in 1989, a time of falling student enrollment, the covenant obligates the city to pay the school district about $1.86 million annually not to develop several school properties throughout the city. With enrollment now rising, the properties occupied by schools, and the district not nearly as financially needy as it was in 1989, the City Council and City Manager James Keene have persistently argued that the basis for the covenant's adoption no longer exists.

The council formally declared its intent in February to remove the provision from any new lease and followed that up in June by stripping the payment for the covenant from the city's 2015 budget.

While school officials had long maintained that a $1.86 million annual loss would be a bitter pill to swallow, on Wednesday morning they indicated that they are willing to do so in the spirit of compromise. Under the terms McGee outlined, the covenant will be dropped and the $1.86 million in city funds will instead be used to "repair, renovate and/or improve" the dilapidated center in south Palo Alto. The school district and the city will also move jointly to come up with a master plan for the entire Middlefield Road campus, in keeping with a recommendation from a community stakeholder group known as the Cubberley Advisory Committee. The master plan is to be completed within five years.

Both sides in the negotiations praised the deal as a victory, despite the compromises each will have to make. School board member Dana Tom called the agreement a "significant step for both the city and the school district" and said it "reflects the changing landscape we experience as a school district and as a community in the many years since the first agreement." Board member Melissa Baten Caswell said the terms "show good work to find a common interest between ourselves and the city."

Yet both she and board member Camille Townsend also raised concerns about the loss of operating revenue because of dropped covenant. Caswell said she was "disappointed" by the need to reduce the budget. But she also said that some concessions were expected and thanked staff from both sides and the large community group for bridging the gap.

"When you have two organizations working together, you can each say what you want and then get louder and louder and see who can win," Caswell said. "But the big gorilla thing doesn't work great for ongoing work together."

Keene told the Weekly that the breakthrough was reached after several productive meetings in recent weeks with McGee, who took over as the district superintendent in August after the resignation of Kevin Skelly. Keene called the agreement "a reflection of how anyone can get things done when you realize that we all have a shared interest in this town."

"Once we got to talking, it was actually pretty easy for us to get to where we are," Keene said of his meetings with McGee. "Clearly, they have some perspectives that are still different from the city's, but the lease I think represents our shared interest in the site."

In a joint press release, McGee lauded the agreement.

"Cubberley is an important community resource. We are indebted to the strong foundation the Cubberley Community Advisory Committee (CCAC) laid for us in their final report and presentation in both substance and tone," McGee stated.

"It is clear that when the PAUSD Board of Education and the City Council can resolve apparent differences through compromise and collaboration, the entire community benefits," he said.

One issue that was less than ideal from the city's perspective is the length of the new lease -- five years -- which is far shorter than the city had hoped for. For the school district, the relatively short term affords flexibility to re-examine its options for Cubberley if district enrollment trends change or new priorities are identified.

Even with the short lease, the deal does offers some relief to existing users of Cubberley Community Center, a diverse group that includes artist studios, physicians, playing-field users, dance studios and Foothill College, which is preparing to depart Cubberley.

The lease also includes a provision that allows the two parties to reconfigure or relocate, by mutual consent, the 8-acre parcel of Cubberley currently used by Foothill. It obligates the city to increase lease payments by 3 percent per year and specifies that the two sides will evenly split either the revenues or the losses stemming from Foothill's replacement by a new tenant.

While the terms have yet to be approved, Keene said he is confident that the council will do so when it meets next week. The council has already discussed the proposed terms in two recent closed sessions. Councilman Larry Klein said Wednesday that he is "delighted about where we are." Though Klein told the Weekly he would have preferred a 10-year plan, he said he is not troubled by the shorter term.

"I think the five-year term will put more pressure on the city and the school district to come up with a long-term plan if at all possible," Klein said.

Related content:

Palo Alto firms up stance in Cubberley negotiations

Palo Alto looks to scrap Cubberley covenant

City, school district at odds over Cubberley provision

What is community worth to you?
Support local journalism.


2 people like this
Posted by Anonymous
a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Nov 12, 2014 at 10:04 pm

Cubberley is a wasting resource and if it continues to be managed the same way, it will continue to be a wasting resource.

Like this comment
Posted by Sea-Seelam REDDY
a resident of College Terrace
on Nov 13, 2014 at 6:42 am

Fantastic Leaders! Max and Jim you deserve the credit for making this happen with the legal and supporting staff.

We all have to take note that 'Cubberley' 'is the center of action for our next generation youth, elderly, and seniors. While the campus looks unattended; there are so many affordable businesses/child development/learning centers/foothill college annex etc., This is the HEART of PALO ALTO on the south end.

So, it is now upon the city council to 'quickly' approve funds to get all the bathrooms upgraded; rooms and walls painted; roof to look like town and country or some thing modern with a phased in approach (not shut down the place and open two years later; no- not that way).

We may eventually need a school. So, we may not want to waste thinking about new layout. Just upgrade with existing layout as is.

Please consider making it look like Embarcadero Town & Country shopping center like.

In essence all the things that are happening there now; need not be disturbed. We need all the services like, ballet class rooms, Bollywood dance, friends of library, foothill college annex and all.

Let us begin with paving the grounds and upgrading the bathrooms. What does it take? Another six months of planning?

Let us do it three months. Please get a good program manager to make it happen.

Palo Alto citizens, please give your input to the city hall and let us get going

With Piazza grocery store, park nearby, Mitchell Library, all our green trees; we have a great neighborhood.

That is why we call our Palo Alto and south Palo Alto a heaven on earth!

Wish all of you happy holidays!!

We are rocking!!

P.S: Let us all unite (the elections are over. Citizens have spoken)

Let us have a nicer looking Cubberley campus a 'year' from now.


1 person likes this
Posted by Resident
a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Nov 13, 2014 at 7:59 am

To some extent, this is a no news item.

Now that Mitchell Park library has left and the new community center is available, much of the present uses of Cubberley will be moving also.

Our schools are going to need this space pronto, and this should be its prime function. Do not put any new uses that does not take this into account.

Sea, this is one time I don't agree with you at all. Putting money into Cubberley which is not in line with PAUSD usage is nothing but a waste of money and energy.

Like this comment
Posted by senor Blogger
a resident of Palo Verde
on Nov 13, 2014 at 11:18 am

The Number $1.8 million is wrong.

The number is more like $7 million.
Refer to the IBRC Infrastructure Report compiled by the Commission and derived from City Financial Disclosures.

1 person likes this
Posted by Gunn Parent
a resident of Gunn High School
on Nov 13, 2014 at 4:40 pm

[Post removed.]

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

All your news. All in one place. Every day.

Chick-fil-A quietly starts delivering out of DoorDash kitchen in Redwood City
By Elena Kadvany | 31 comments | 4,001 views

Disposing of Disposables
By Sherry Listgarten | 24 comments | 3,062 views

By Cheryl Bac | 0 comments | 1,529 views

Differentiating Grief from Clinical Depression
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 1,139 views

Anonymous Sources: Facebook and YouTube suppressing important questions and discussion
By Douglas Moran | 20 comments | 1,015 views