County opts for new strategy to fight TB

Plan is set to counter unexpected jump in cases

Tuberculosis rates are on the decline throughout the U.S., but in Santa Clara County the numbers remain high. With more cases of tuberculosis per year than most states, county officials are looking to shift the approach to fighting the spread of the disease, starting with a revamp in the way patients are tested for the disease.

Pulmonary tuberculosis, or TB, is a bacterial infection that most often affects the lungs. The disease is highly contagious, and spreads when an infected person talks, coughs, or sneezes tuberculosis bacteria into the air. Tuberculosis deaths are rare in the United States, but ranks second for leading cause of death from infection worldwide.

On Monday, March 24, Santa Clara County health officials announced that tuberculosis cases have increased in the county for the first time in six years, up to 181 from 176. It was also announced that the county planned to eliminate universal screening of children entering school in favor of a risk-assessment system.

Dr. Teeb Al-Samarrai, the TB Controller for Santa Clara County, said use of universal testing began in 1989 in response to rising tuberculosis rates in the late 80s and 90s. The mandate was to identify children who had been exposed to active tuberculosis and had been infected by latent, or silent, tuberculosis. As the tuberculosis rates started to decline, the Center for Disease Control and Prevention and the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that testing shift away from the universal mandate and focus more on children at greatest risk of getting the disease.

The problem with continuing mandatory, universal screening is that it's both an inefficient and problematic way to test for tuberculosis, according to Al-Samarrai. The mandate tested a high number of students who were at very low-risk of contracting tuberculosis, and resulted in a lot of false positives. This meant more unnecessary testing and chest X-rays for healthy children who had not contracted the disease. Santa Clara County is the only county in the state that still uses mandatory tuberculosis testing for entry into the school system.

In the coming months, Santa Clara County will be phasing out universal testing for tuberculosis. Effective June 1 of this year the county will instead do a universal test for risk factors, and screen for tuberculosis if the child is at high risk. Health care providers will fill out a risk assessment in the form of a check list for children, and both the list and any subsequent tests will be required to enter the school system.

Dr. Daniel Shin, infectious disease specialist at El Camino Hospital, said he agrees with the county's decision to move away from universal screening of children entering school. "The new approach is more accurate," Shin said. "It's better to get a risk assessment and test students at high risk instead of testing every student."

High-risk factors for tuberculosis include whether a person was born in a country where tuberculosis is widespread Those countries include India, China and Southeast Asian countries like the Philippines and Vietnam. An overwhelming 91 percent of tuberculosis cases in Santa Clara County have been in people who were born in a different country.

Shin said other risk factors include whether the person has a chronic illness, such as diabetes, HIV or is on kidney dialysis. People are also at higher risk if they have been exposed to someone with active tuberculosis, have an abnormal chest X-ray or live in a densely populated living space, like a nursing home.

The emphasis on testing children is not because they are more likely to have active tuberculosis. Al-Samarrai said only five of the 181 tuberculosis cases last year were in children, and a majority of tuberculosis deaths occur between ages 25 and 64. But children are more likely to go from a latent form of tuberculosis into active tuberculosis in their lifetime, and screening children at high risk before they enter school can catch any early cases of the disease.

Al-Samarrai said one reason why it's important to diagnose the disease during its latent phase is that the first line of drugs used to treat active tuberculosis haven't changed in 50 years. Treating active tuberculosis involves taking four antibiotics with harsh side effects for several months.

Shin said that El Camino Hospital has treated anywhere from 11 to 18 people annually between 2011 and 2013. The hospital takes a number of precautions for every case. If anyone suspects a patient has tuberculosis, that patient is isolated in a negative pressure room, and anyone who sees that patient must wear a mask.

Part of the change is to also spread awareness about the risk factors for tuberculosis and recognizing who is at risk. Al-Samarrai said risk assessments should be done at the doctor's office, and physicians and pediatricians are being told to ask about a patient's exposure to high risk factors. Al-Samarrai said the county and health care providers need to let parents know about the risk factors, and take initiative to get their children screened.

With risk assessment, early detection and treatment, Al-Samarrai said the rates of active tuberculosis will hopefully decline in Santa Clara County. With today's modern medicine and technology, Al-Samarrai said tuberculosis shouldn't be a problem. "It's curable. It's treatable. Nobody should be dying from tuberculosis," she said.


Like this comment
Posted by Joe
a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood
on Apr 8, 2014 at 1:32 pm

> An overwhelming 91 percent of tuberculosis cases in Santa Clara County
> have been in people who were born in a different country

So why not require all new immigrants from these countries to undergo a complete physical, and periodic testing for the kinds of diseases that are considered a problem in Santa Clara County?

Testing the children is one way to indirectly locate the active carriers, but it is very oblique, compared to going after those from the countries identified in the article.

Amazing how difficult basics, like sound public health policies can be, when public officials get tied up in political correctness, and all of its convoluted byproducts.

Like this comment
Posted by scanlon
a resident of Southgate
on Apr 8, 2014 at 6:12 pm

[Post removed.]

Like this comment
Posted by ChrisC
a resident of College Terrace
on Apr 9, 2014 at 11:04 am

ChrisC is a registered user.

To Joe: The US government requires TB screening in the country of origin for visas. I can't remember if it's just for long-term visas, or from which countries, but there are many ways to get around this in some countries, bribery and such. However, that would seem the appropriate place to catch the problem .. before emigration to the US. Period checking here of the same person wouldn't mean anything except harassment, because I believe the implication of the article is that someone has brought it from the country, then certainly could've spread it to others if living in crowded conditions.

Like this comment
Posted by jerry99
a resident of Barron Park
on Apr 9, 2014 at 12:19 pm

[Post removed.]

Like this comment
Posted by Mimi
a resident of Community Center
on Apr 9, 2014 at 2:17 pm

To get a green card (permanent residency) you have to be tested for prior exposure. If you test positive, you have to get a Chest X-Ray to see if you are currently infectious. However, TB can reactivate decades later. Only 10% of people become ill the year they are exposed. Another 10% reactivate years later. That is where an astute medical community comes in, and why we need universal health care. We can offer, but not force, people to take preventive medication. (80% will never become ill in fact)
Remember, there are elderly American born people who were exposed in the USA in their childhood.
And, American born folks who do "Adventure Travel" are exposed as well. Several of my family and friends "converted" their PPD (TB screening test) after travel in India. I don't want to focus just on India, it could happen in many developing nations.
So yes, 90% of the cases come from people born elsewhere, but if you've enjoyed "off the beaten track" vacations, you, too are at risk.

Like this comment
Posted by Mike
a resident of University South
on Apr 9, 2014 at 2:44 pm

[Post removed.]

Like this comment
Posted by j99
a resident of Barron Park
on Apr 9, 2014 at 5:08 pm

[Post removed.]

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Burger chain Shake Shack to open in Palo Alto
By Elena Kadvany | 5 comments | 2,621 views

Eat, Surf, Love
By Laura Stec | 3 comments | 982 views

Couples: So You Married Mom or Dad . . .
By Chandrama Anderson | 0 comments | 969 views

The Cost of Service
By Aldis Petriceks | 2 comments | 605 views