Despite outcry about radiation exposure at an adjacent preschool, the city's zoning administrator approved a cell phone tower to go on top of Mountain View's First Presbyterian Church Wednesday evening.
Unless the decision is appealed to the City Council, the church at the corner of Miramonte and Cuesta streets will soon have wireless antennae devices on its roof to be enclosed in a new steeple on the chapel building on the south east corner of the property, across from the main chapel.
Zoning administrator Peter Gilli said FCC regulations do not allow him to reject the tower because of the neighbor's concerns with what may be cancer-causing radiation, unless RF levels were above the FCC threshold. That left him no choice but to approve the project if it was architecturally acceptable, which he said it was.
Parents of the Little Acorn preschool, located 50-75 feet from the cell tower location, are concerned about exposing 70 or so children to the cell tower's radiation. As of Wednesday afternoon 58 people signed an online petition in opposition, and 15 others have signed the paper version.
Gilli said that his approval of the cell tower was on the condition that parents would be able to pull their children from the preschool without being penalized with any fees.
While the church will make money from leasing the space to Clear Wireless LLC, parents said the preschool may lose enrollment because of it.
An RF study indicated that the theoretical radiation emitted from the cell tower to the site and the surrounding homes was well below the FCC's acceptable levels, Gilli noted. Applicant Clearwire LLC's representative Gordon Bell agreed to do before and after RF testing to back up that claim, and post results at the church. He said the tests would show almost "undetectable" levels of radiation.
Neighbors were still concerned, saying that there was no scientific proof that such a cell tower is safe. One resident noted that other countries, such as Austria, have much stricter regulations that would not allow such a cell tower.
"People are concerned about radiation," said preschool parent W. Tsang. "Does the community really want this or need this or can it be explored somewhere else?"
About a dozen parents and neighbors spoke in opposition to the proposal. Some said the value of their homes would drop.
"My biggest concern is that we were just informed about this," said a neighbor and preschool parent. "There's no data to let us know this is safe."
Parents and residential neighbors said they had only recently learned about the proposal and Gilli joined them in disappointment over the church's failure to notify everyone who might be affected. But Gilli said the proposal had already been delayed once.
"It should not be a legal obligation for the church, but a moral obligation to reach out to the community," said neighbor Wendy Yee.
A church representative said the church had notified the pre-school, along with other tenants on the property, including a group of Boy Scouts and another church on the site called the Open Door Church. No one responded to the church with concerns and it is unknown how many people really had the notice passed onto them.
"I'm a member of that church and I didn't even know," said one women who lives nextdoor and said residential neighbors were the most seriously impacted. "We can't get away from it."
Pastor Tim Boyer said a committee of church members had been discussing the proposal since July.
"We wouldn't do anything on this campus that would hurt god's children," Boyer said Tuesday.
After examining research compiled by the cell phone company and having discussed the issue with church members, Boyer said he was confident the cell phone antennas were safe.
"I would be more concerned with that (cell phone) in your hand that I would be with that (cell phone tower) on top of the church."
Boyer declined to say how much the church would be paid to host the antennas, saying "I don't think that's important." The reason for allowing the antennas was more to "provide a service," Boyer said, especially since the site is within a line of sight of El Camino Hospital.
Clearwire representative Gordon Bell said that previous proposals to put the antenna on top of a commercial building across the street or on top of the Safeway nearby were both denied.
The project approved is for "a wireless communications facility within a new steeple feature on the roof of an existing church, including a GPS antenna, three microwave dishes, three panel antennas/RRUs and one equipment cabinet in a fence enclosure."
Construction of the antennas may begin in January unless opponents win an appeal to the City Council.
Residents be forewarned, Bell said it would be impossible to find a location for a cell tower in the area that was away from homes. And Gilli said applications for cell towers were becoming more prevalent as service providers prepare for faster service, such as 4G.