A Pantser Brought to Heel | On the Page | Nick Taylor | Palo Alto Online |

Local Blogs

On the Page

By Nick Taylor

About this blog: This blog is a place for conversation about books. I post reviews of what I'm reading--lots of contemporary fiction, but also classics and the occasional work of narrative nonfiction. I am always looking for new books to read, so ...  (More)

View all posts from Nick Taylor

A Pantser Brought to Heel

Uploaded: Jan 13, 2016
A few weeks after my novel The Setup Man was published in March 2014, I got a call from my agent, who reported that the publishers were asking when they were going to pages of a sequel. This shouldn’t have surprised me, but it did -- just as everything about writing a detective series has surprised me. I replied that I had a few chapters (not a lie!) but that I’d need a few weeks to hammer out the plot outline they were requesting as part of a proposal. “Two weeks should give you plenty of time,” my agent said. “We can’t wait longer than that.”

Two weeks was plenty of time? To fumble around, maybe. I had never written a novel from an outline, much less from an outline inspected by a renowned New York publisher. The fact that the publisher wanted to see a proposal was a good problem to have, as they say, but it was an unfamiliar one. I took the thirty meandering pages I had drafted so far (I had at least considered the possibility of a sequel!) and attempted to extrapolate where the story “wanted” to go. There’s a line of thinking among fiction writers that plot comes from character, and that to find the plot of a novel in progress you must “listen” to what the characters “tell” you. I’ve always thought this was the worst kind of bullshit, but I never really learned how to make a plot any other way. So I was stuck staring at a blank page, wondering how I could determine the further adventures of Johnny Adcock, relief pitcher PI, if I couldn’t follow him through the scenes as they occurred.

Like a lot of obstacles, this one was mostly mental. I retrained my brain to conceive of the story in the language of summary (think movie synopsis) rather than scene. And I met my two-week deadline with a cleanly-edited, forty-page proposal. My agent and editor suggested changes, which I implemented, and the proposal went upstairs, to the decision makers. They offered a few more plot notes but blessed the thing with a modest deal.

Now I just had to write it.

Again: nice problem to have. In fact, I felt pretty confident as I started drafting the book. Writing from an outline was pretty cool, I discovered. I always knew what was going to happen on the next page. No more agonizing! No writer’s block! The writing went smoothly, and I submitted the first draft on schedule about six months later. It wasn’t my favorite work to date, but it was faithful to the outline, and best of all, it was on time.

My editor took a few weeks to read the draft, then called and asked if we could talk. His tone wasn’t ominous (I’m not sure he’s capable of ominous) but it wasn’t upbeat, either. “So,” he began, “I’m seeing lots of good things in this draft...”

Some writers complain that outlines cramp their style, and they refuse to use them. “Pantsers,” they call themselves -- as in “by the seat of their pants,” which is how they plot their books. A surprising percentage of crime writers are pantsers, along with nearly all literary novelists. I myself had been a pantser right up until the opportunity came to switch over to Team Outline. I too had believed that writing from an outline was confining -- and I’d been right, but not in the way I expected. The real problem with writing from an outline is that it locks you into bad choices. All those “pantsy” plot points I came up with during that two-week sprint to the proposal deadline? They were now fleshed out in my manuscript. No surprise, the ones that seemed flimsy in the outline were even flimsier in scene. The editor was right -- there were lots of good things in the first draft of Double Switch. The problem was that as a novel, it sucked.

Next time: What to do when half your book is dead.

Nick Taylor (as T.T. Monday) will appear in conversation with author Kris Calvin on Tuesday, March 1, at 7:30pm at Kepler's Books in Menlo Park. The event is free and open to the public.
What is it worth to you?


Posted by Backwards Was Best, a resident of University South,
on Jan 16, 2016 at 8:17 pm

My high school teachers always required an outline before the first draft. Being temperamentally unable to work from an outline (I could see the flow much more clearly working with the actual prose), I would draft the assignment at light speed, outline it, and hand in the outline as required. The result always earned high marks for coherence and thoroughness, plus I had the draft in hand to polish almost at leisure.

Not sure that would work for a novel, though.

Posted by <a href="http://thetermpapers.net/">thetermpapers</a>, a resident of Duveneck/St. Francis,
on Jan 18, 2016 at 4:52 am

<a href="http://thetermpapers.net/">thetermpapers</a> is a registered user.

I completely agree with you, as seriously, two weeks is completely not enough to write a novel, even when you have an outline, moreover, they should not set such a strict deadline, as it is not an article for magazine, it is novel that people will read for many years.

Posted by Nick Taylor, a Palo Alto Online blogger,
on Jan 19, 2016 at 11:07 am

Nick Taylor is a registered user.

@thetermpapers: Sorry I wasn't clear about the two-week deadline. It was to write an outline, not a whole novel. You're right--that would have been crazy!

Follow this blogger.
Sign up to be notified of new posts by this blogger.



Post a comment

Sorry, but further commenting on this topic has been closed.

Stay informed.

Get the day's top headlines from Palo Alto Online sent to your inbox in the Express newsletter.

Analysis/paralysis: The infamous ‘Palo Alto Process’ must go
By Diana Diamond | 6 comments | 2,262 views

Common Ground
By Sherry Listgarten | 3 comments | 1,792 views

The Time and Cost Savings of Avoiding a Long Commute
By Steve Levy | 6 comments | 1,616 views

Planting a Fall Garden?
By Laura Stec | 5 comments | 1,075 views


Sign-up now for 5K Run/Walk, 10k Run, Half Marathon

The 39th annual Moonlight Run and Walk is Friday evening, September 29. Join us under the light of the full Harvest Moon on a 5K walk, 5K run, 10K run or half marathon. Complete your race in person or virtually. Proceeds from the race go to the Palo Alto Weekly Holiday Fund, benefiting local nonprofits that serve families and children in Santa Clara and San Mateo Counties.