Original post made
on Aug 22, 2008
This story contains 94 words.
If you are a paid subscriber, check to make sure you have
Otherwise our system cannot recognize you as having full free access to our site.
If you are a paid print subscriber and haven't yet set up an online account,
to get your online account activated.
Thank you to the Weekly for reporting this story responsibly. Of course, someone started a flyer campaign to save the "magnificent tree" -- without bothering to read the arborists' report or contact anyone in the city or in the neighborhood who knew about trees.
It's unfortunate that this eucalyptus tree could not be saved, but the critical mistake of topping this tree was made decades ago, when the dangers of topping a tree that had outgrown its space was not known. In this case, the trunk rot was serious, and the risk to anyone in the library or in the mini-park around the library was very real.
For those for whom it's not convenient to review the arborists' reports at one of the Palo Alto libraries, here are a couple general references:
Why topping hurts trees:
Topping your eucalyptus trees could be dangerous
Quote: ". . .topping your eucalyptus will create a hazardous condition. Dormant buds below the topping cuts will sprout and quickly grow back to the original height of the tree. These sprouts are weakly attached to the outermost rings of original branch wood.. . these sprouts are easily torn from the branch ends by wind or weight, particularly if the topping cut becomes decayed."
Moral of the story: do a little homework before using a lot of paper in a misguided attempt to "save" a tree that happens to be tall. If the tree is on public property, you can bet your last dollar that a careful assessment has been made before a recommendation to remove such a tree, even when it's a non-native eucalyptus.
That guy on the bicycle needs to cut back on all the voyeurism!
Be interesting to see how they grind the roots out without damaging the building.
Thanks for the explanation of the danger of topping trees.
Is it necessary to grind the roots out? The stump could be left as a reminder. It looks not pretty, though, because is rotten inside. But may it will give sprouts?...
The trunk looks like some very sophisticated sculpture. It would be great to use it for some craftwork...
"""That guy on the bicycle needs to cut back on all the voyeurism!""" I don't like local bicyclist for they mess with cars and run stop signs. But this guy on the photo is doing nothing wrong.