Cars should be able to turn left without an arrow
Original post made by Craig on Jan 26, 2007
Is anyone else frustrated by this regulation? While helpful during rush hour, the regulation is ludicrous during the early morning and late evening hours. Normally, the light on El Camino will be green, and there will be no other cars anywhere in sight (literally, I could crawl across the street on my hands and knees, and oncoming traffic would not reach me), yet I am unable to make a simple turn.
I'm not advocating a complete expulsion of the arrow. As I said, turn protection is imperative during heavy traffic hours. I simply think the cycle should go as follows: green light for North/South (N/S cars can make left turns if appropriate), then green arrows for N/S (allowing protected turns), then green light for East/West, then green arrows for E/W.
If licensed drivers are trusted to drive sixty (or more) miles per hour on the highway, then I cannot fathom why we are not trusted to determine if oncoming traffic is at a sufficient distance to permit a left hand turn. The safety risk of such a regulation change should be negligible, since risk aversion would prevent us from making an unprotected turn unless absolutely certain that oncoming traffic poses no threat.
The benefits of such a change are numerous. First, congestion at intersections would decrease. Second, drivers would save precious time. Third, automobiles would be idling less, which would slightly reduce fuel consumption and environmental externalities.
I'm curious to hear everyone's thoughts on this issue. Thanks for reading!
on Jan 26, 2007 at 2:47 pm
I agree completely, Craig. Perhaps the red arrows make sense during rush hour, but as you say, there are plenty of times when the street is completely deserted but you must wait for a complete cycle for a green arrow.
Perhaps the ideal solution would be to have the red arrows on a timer so that they only occurred during rush hour or other particularly busy times of day.
on Jan 26, 2007 at 3:54 pm
I ride my Bike everywhere in Palo Alto.
Ever heard of our "Addiction to Oil"?
Anything to make cars slow down is great.
on Jan 26, 2007 at 5:12 pm
In response to Anon, cars idling needlessly at an intersection rather than decreases, actually increases the consumption of oil.