Post a New Topic
Original post made
by Family of Fans, College Terrace,
on Jul 22, 2007
Seconded! My kids are much older now (15 and 12) but I still read the whole thing aloud, since I've been doing that all the way along.
We were riveted, and have spent much time today talking about lingering questions, observations, and (yes) sorrows. What a rich tapestry of story she gave us! How lucky that Harry Potter was part of our kids' growing up.
I'm saddened to see the Harry Potter tale ending, but want to applaud Kepler's for hosting such a fun, exciting night last Friday. JK Rowling has written seven phenomenal books -- thanks for the adventure JK!
I really liked this book. It satisfyingly tied up many loose ends, and the ending was touching and satisfying and made sense in the context of the Harry Potter world. I have to say, I liked it almost as much as the first (which was my favorite) -- probably only ALMOST as much because it was so delightful to enter that world for the first time.
What did others think (without giving too much away)?
We Love Harry Potter and are so happy with Deathly Hallows! I am sad that there is no more coming.
Check out the hour long Dateline special this Sunday.
I have just finished book 7 of Harry Potter and wish to discuss some lingering questions with others who have finished the book.
How long can we wait without spoiling the book for others who haven't finished it yet? Could we have a spoilers section separate from this section?
Yes, please keep spoilers away. We have two copies of the book in this house and I am not sure when I will get down to reading it. As it is, those who have read and those who have not are doing their best to spoil it for me!!
Parent, if you don't want spoilers, then don't open threads labeled "Harry Potter." Push yourself away from this forum and go read the book instead.
I would, but there is always someone else reading it.
Loved the book...until the last chapter and the epilogue.
I don't think this is a spoiler because it is a question about an earlier book. Can anyone remember and tell me how Draco Mafloy got Dumbledore's wand and how D got it back?
Hoping not to be a spoiler, I'll say that I know what you mean, GSB, but I was surprised to find myself also strangely touched by the finale.
Again, hoping not to be a spoiler, and if you have not read the book you may not want to read my question, but . . .
was anyone else shocked and did anyone else feel it was compeltely out of character for Mrs. Weasley suddenly to blurt out "You Bitch!"
I think I agree that this thread is for those who have already read the "Deathly Hallows". This is for discussion of the book.
So here is my question and I hope some of you will respond.
How does Harry winning the hawthorne wand from Draco make Harry master of the Elder wand?????????
The only way you can become the master is by taking it FROM the most recent master. So Draco became the master by taking it from Dumbledore. When Harry took it from him, rather than being given it, he became the new master. I think.
Natasha, Harry did not take the elder wand from Draco. He took the hawthorne wand! How does taking one wand from someone make one the master of another wand?
hmmmmmm. need to reread both to see if I can understand that process. tricky.
Still waiting for an answer.
I don't think this is a spoiler because it is a question about an earlier book. Can anyone remember and tell me how Draco Mafloy got Dumbledore's wand and how D got it back? Is this in the prior book or which book?
SPOILER ALERT - ONLY FOR THOSE WHO FINISHED BOOK 7
I found an answer to my own question on some fan blog. I can't find it again but had time to copy the bit below and send it to myself in an email. (Since I use the library Internet, I ran out of time.)
HERE IT IS
Why was Draco the rightful owner of the Elder Wand? How did that work against Voldemort? Nick
Deep breath: When Draco disarmed Dumbledore at the end of book 6, the Elder Wand won by the headmaster when he dueled Grindelwald passed its allegiance to young Malfoy, not to Snape, whose ''murder'' of Dumbledore was prearranged and therefore not a defeat. Then Harry won Draco's wand at Malfoy Manor. So when Voldemort tried to kill Harry with the Elder Wand and Harry countered using Draco's wand, the two wands effectively canceled each other out. The Elder Wand realized it was attacking Draco's wand, refused to act against its master, and rebounded the Killing Curse back onto Voldemort. The Dark Lord never had a chance.
Thanks Harry Potter?
This crap is fiction.
You might as well piss in the wind.
Harry is not real.
He is a fictitous little nerd, don't forget.
Or has all the hocus pocus delluded you?
Wake up. Go outside, where the real fantasy is.
Since I read the library book and have returned it, I need to ask other readers of book 7 whether or not Lupin, as well as Tonks, was killed. I can't remember and I was confused by Rowling saying, in an interview, that their child was an orphan.
Please let me know if both parents were killed off in book 7.
yes, Remus and Tonks were both killed in the final battle. She didn't explain what happened to their baby, Teddy, but he was left with Tonk's mother, and Ted Tonks (Tonks' father) was killed earlier in the book.
As for the Elder wand, it recognized as a new master whoever had conquered its master (DRaco), whether or not he had the wand with him at the time. So the Elder Wand somehow knew that Harry had defeated Draco, recognized Harry as its new master, and rebounded the spell on Voldermort.
I wish I knew what happened to George. Or was it Fred? :0)
Natasha, The epilogue said what happened to Teddy. He turned out all right. It was Fred who died in the last battle. I don't remember if George was mentioned in the epilogue, but he probably continued his shop.
What I don't recall (and am rereading "The Half-Blood Prince to find out hopefully) when and how Draco obtained the Elder wand from Dumbledore and how D got it back. It was buried with him.
What happened to Luna Lovegood?
Blush, Must be getting forgetful. Draco disarmed Dumbledore at the end of book 6, so he became master of the Elder wand. My questions above is dumb; wish I could edit it out!
Here I go with another question. Why is Harry Potter a "half-blood"?
Weren't both his parents wizards? If not, which one wasn't, James or Lilly?
I think, technically speaking, that Harry was a quarter blood. Lily was obviously half blood because her sister, Petunia, was not a witch and her parents had to be told by school authorities that she was a witch and deserved a place at Hogwarts, rather than Snape's parents who were told by owl. How Hogwarts knows who is born as a witch in a muggle family is not explained.
James was seemingly full blood because he was a true descendant of the Peverell family, although through his mother's line rather than his father's (or else his name would have been Peverell).
I am now entering this discussion because I have finished reading the book. I didn't enjoy this particular book as much as I expected because (and I know this sounds silly) it was too far fetched. The witching world seemed credible and the other books all worked well in this scenario. This book just didn't work for me. The fact that one dark wizard could suddenly turn the whole wizarding world into two sides of a civil war just sounded too unlikely. The knowledge about Harry and his special role in this also sounds too unlikely to cause this to happen. I did like the ending, although the chapter with Dumbledore, which needed to get in somewhere, made little sense to me. I would have preferred this to be an epilogue and left the existing epiglogue out altogether. I would rather have been able to guess at what happened in their futures.
Speaking of the epilogue, it did bring back to mind that this is a children's book written for children rather than adults. It reminded me of the first book in style and content. My daughter reminded me that JK had actually written this epilogue before any of the other books and that may be the reason. Children's books like to tie up the who marries who and what happens next whereas adult books tend not to. The other reason I was not happy with the epilogue is that I didn't like the idea that everything went back to the happy way before. In real life, when something epic happens, the life before is destroyed and something new has to evolve. I would have preferred to see the old Hogwarts being destroyed and a new school being instituted. I would like to have seen perhaps more integration with the muggle world and perhaps more between world happenings. That is probably my adult attitude coming out, but it would have been more satisfying than the everything returned to the old way, just without some of the characters scenario that occurred.
But both Harry's parents were magical: his mother was a witch and his father was a wizard. So I don't see how he could be 1/4 blood. Perhaps 3/4 blood? It's all dumb anyway, a magical racism.
The books are inconsistent in other ways, but this is fiction and not all the explanations make sense to me either. It is too much to expect logic throughout.
I didn't like book 7 that much and thought the epilogue was a bad idea. I much prefered book 6, "The Half-Blood Prince".
Can anyone help me? There's a hippogriff in my backyard and I don't know what to do with it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Hagrid won't answer my emails - waah waah!!!
Anyone remember who was the Professor of Dark Arts during Harry's first year at Hogwarts and what happened to him/her (Socerer's Stone)??
Wasn't it Professor Quirrel, the stutterer, who had Voldemort somehow embedded in the back of his head so he had to wear a turban to cover it up? Sorcereor's stone . . . I think that was the one. Anyone else?
I just checked and it was Quirrell, and he died when Voldemort fled his body after Harry won the fight.
Okay, Hagrid said that he will pick up the hippogriff during the next holiday. He's busy at Hogwarts getting ready for the new term. He would not explain what the creature was doing in the Bay Area or even in the USA. I just found it in my back garden one day this summer.
Luckily, it's a vegetarian but buying all those veggies is costing me my savings. It eats tons a day! Anyone with a garden who wishes to contribute to this cute and hungry creature's nutrition, please write so in this thread. No, I haven't named it and don't know its sex. Hagrid is being very mysterious. It is a gentle and affectionate creature and my cats love sleeping on its back.
I'm a 7th year at Hogwarts. I started in Harry's 4th year, when Mad Eye was the Defense against the Dark Arts teacher. I know what the hippogriff was doing in the USA! This was an exchange program for amaqzing creatures. That's all I can say about that!
Hippogriffs can eat any vegetation at all, including nettles and weeds of all sorts. So put a leash on it and take it to fields that are overgrown. They are better than goats!!!!
Thank you, Natalie. I've given the care of the hippogriff to a friend who lives in the hills. A better home for it! I've informed Hagrid. No shortage of grass and weeds up in the hills!
Of course, I miss this amazing creature and so do my cats. C'est la vie.
Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.
Post a comment
Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online.
Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information
We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.
Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?
- Barron Park
- Charleston Gardens
- Charleston Meadows
- College Terrace
- Community Center
- Crescent Park
- Downtown North
- Duveneck/St. Francis
- Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
- Esther Clark Park
- Evergreen Park
- Greater Miranda
- Green Acres
- Greendell/Walnut Grove
- Leland Manor/Garland Drive
- Meadow Park
- Monroe Park
- Old Palo Alto
- Palo Alto Hills
- Palo Alto Orchards
- Palo Verde
- South of Midtown
- St. Claire Gardens
- The Greenhouse
- Triple El
- University South
- Woodland Ave. area (East Palo Alto)
- Addison School
- Barron Park School
- Duveneck School
- Egan Middle School (Los Altos)
- El Carmelo School
- Escondido School
- Fairmeadow School
- Gunn High School
- Hoover School
- JLS Middle School
- Jordan Middle School
- Juana Briones School
- Nixon School
- Ohlone School
- Palo Alto High School
- Palo Verde School
- Santa Rita (Los Altos)
- Terman Middle School
- Walter Hays School
- another community
- Another Palo Alto neighborhood
- East Palo Alto
- Los Altos
- Los Altos Hills
- Menlo Park
- Mountain View
- Portola Valley
Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.
Local picks on 2015 Michelin Bib Gourmand list
By Elena Kadvany | 6 comments | 3,426 views
Ode to Brussels Sprout
By Laura Stec | 20 comments | 2,617 views
Go Giants! Next Stop: World Series!
By Chandrama Anderson | 1 comment | 1,942 views
Politics: Empty appeals to "innovation"
By Douglas Moran | 9 comments | 1,379 views
It's Dog-O-Ween this Saturday!
By Cathy Kirkman | 2 comments | 403 views
Home & Real Estate
Shop Palo Alto
Send News Tips
Circulation & Delivery
Mountain View Voice
© 2014 Palo Alto Online
All rights reserved.