Worried about rising hunger among her patients, a Stanford University physician has launched a summer food program at an East Palo Alto school. Lisa Chamberlain, an assistant professor of pediatrics who has practiced medicine at the Ravenswood Family Health Center in East Palo Alto since 2004, said a growing number of patients have been answering "no" to the standard question asked of all: "At the end of the month, do you have enough money for food and rent?"
Read the full story here Web Link posted Saturday, July 21, 2012, 2:39 PM
Posted by Marrol, a resident of the Embarcadero Oaks/Leland neighborhood, on Jul 21, 2012 at 3:37 pm
I applaud this physician for her sense of humanity, compassion, and dedication. In addition to programs such as these, there should be an equal emphasis on providing people with family planning education. They too have a responsibility in making the decision as to whether or not they can afford to properly support a family. I'm not suggesting that people should be excluded from having children, but how about doing so when they can afford it and won't cause a drain on valuable resources.
Posted by Teach-People-To-Fish, a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood, on Jul 22, 2012 at 7:34 am
Given the lack of details in this article, one is left with the impression that the hungry lady in the article is in the US illegally—leaving us with the fundamental question of just what obligations US citizens/taxpayers have to feed/house/clothe/compensate people who ignore our laws, and make their way into our cities—only to find that life is hard, even here in the US. If this lady were actually here illegally, the article does the situation no justice by failing to research her background, to find out what life is like in the place she was residing prior to coming to the US.
Given that summertime routinely sees local markets brimming with fresh produce that is inexpensively priced, it is difficult to understand how someone can not find food at this time of year. Of course, if people are inclined to buy more expensive pre-processed food, this does mean they will spend more money than if they do the preparation themselves.
We also have to remember that many foreign nationals send money home, which reduces their own purchasing power here, and often pushes them towards public assistance—forcing US taxpayers into subsidizing people all over the world (but heavily in Mexico and Central America) indirectly.
And we are also left with the question, if these people can not find work in the Silicon Valley—perhaps they should move to somewhere that is less expensive, and they can find work.
After reading this article it's not hard to revisit the situation of whether to give a hungry man a fish to eat, or teach him how to fish so that he can feed himself for life.
Posted by Concerned Retiree, a resident of the Midtown neighborhood, on Jul 23, 2012 at 11:22 am
The irony here is that 139 years of prison maintenance for the murderer in the adjoining story would go a long way in providing food for the hungry and medical care for most of all us who find medical care over-priced whether or not we are insured.
We should dispose of criminals whose DNA double checks their guilt. [Portion removed by Palo Alto Online staff.]
Posted by Charlie, a resident of the College Terrace neighborhood, on Jul 23, 2012 at 11:31 am
Reading this definitely makes me want to help, but I am not sure what the most direct way to contribute would be. Second Harvest? Ravenswood Education fund? Could the reporter ask Dr. Chamberlain how people who want to support her efforts might get involved -- where to send funds, whether she needs volunteers, etc.
Thank you for brining this to our attention. There is no excuse for hunger in our community.
Posted by Lisa Chamberlain (pediatrician in the story), a resident of Stanford, on Jul 23, 2012 at 5:03 pm
I have been really amazed by the depth of community response to this story - and thanks to all of you who have been moved to want to help. The real heroes in our community who address this issue, year in and year out, are the leadership and staff at the Second Harvest Food Bank (www.shfb.org - who serve the entire peninsula) and the Ecumenical Hunger Program (www.ehpcares.org who serve East Palo Alto). I know both groups well, having been lucky to have met and worked with them over the last couple years. I cannot say enough good things about them. Please do consider supporting them with either your time or resources if you are able.
Posted by Perspective, a resident of the Greater Miranda neighborhood, on Jul 23, 2012 at 6:51 pm
Dear WWJD: The Dude 2,000 years ago spoke about giving from your own pocket, heart and time, not taking from others to give others' pockets, hearts and time to what you want to give to. In other words, exactly what these guys are doing, donating from themselves to what they believe in.
Posted by Perspective, a resident of the Greater Miranda neighborhood, on Jul 24, 2012 at 5:43 am
WWJD: I can see Teach-people's point. The article implies that the people being fed are not here legally. In fact, it says nothing about them. Frankly, even being here illegally has not stopped anyone from getting an EBT card ( formerly called Food Stamps) since 2002, when it no longer was a requirement to prove you were a citizen to sign up for food stamps. So, it IS confusing to me,..why aren't these people getting EBT cards and able to feed themselves?
Not that anyone is for hungry people, of course,and as Americans we don't let people starve..but I DO wonder, where is the EBT money going? Sort of like the millions of uninsured who already qualified for MedicAid/Cal, why aren't they already signed up, why are we calling them "uninsured" when they already qualify for MediCal/Aid? I can't help but wonder the same thing here. I have to ask, why are they hungry, where is the EBT money?
Posted by Perspective, a resident of the Greater Miranda neighborhood, on Jul 25, 2012 at 6:33 am
Yes, WWJD, I am certain the Dude from 2,000 years ago would have approved of distorting what is written, casting aspersions of being "for starvation" on whomever you wish to smear, and sarcastically assuming you have the lock on WWJD. I am thinking you have a direct line somewhere to the Dude from 2,000 years ago, which gives you your moral superiority and gifted understanding of all things?
Posted by Resident, a resident of Another Palo Alto neighborhood, on Jul 25, 2012 at 10:13 am
How about "Render to Caesar that which is Caesar's".
Back in first century Israel, there were no social services and family loyalty was the only backup for the elderly, disabled and chronically sick. The Pharisees and Priests were more interested in religious law than in helping those in need. Begging was used by those who literally had no other course of action and was possibly a reason for arrest by Roman authorities who could act under their own ideas rather than accepted Roman law. In fact there were no laws to help the poor, the sick, the elderly or the downtrodden Jews. That is why the Jews were looking for a Savior and didn't recognise Him because they were expecting a military style King to overpower the Romans from their land.
Taking the Dude's words out of context is fine, but it is still worth mentioning the context to show the difference between 1st century Israel and 21st century USA.