Post a New Topic
Original post made
on Jun 29, 2011
Did Ms. Williams know the car was being repossessed rather than stolen?
does it matter? you cant protect property with deadly force.
Yes it does matter. If someone stole my car, I'd chase them down too!
This just goes to show how easy it is to let your temper get out of control and make a tough situation much worse.
But, if criminals knew that people would aggressively defend themselves and their property, crime would likely plummet. This is an example of how short term it may be wisest to give in to criminals, but longer term, doing so may encourage more crime and perhaps ultimately more violence.
That said, I'm not sure whether this woman knew it was a legitimate repossession rather than a theft.
@ Just a thought
Let's give everyone guns. Then when anyone trespasses on someone else's property, the property owner gets to shoot. That will surely put a stop to criminal trespassing. Or if someone steal's Timmy's beach ball -- run 'em down? Or better yet, shoot them! That'll put a stop to personal property theft.
Such sarcasm or taking things to extremes is rarely helpful for a productive discourse.
The point remains that more aggressive resisting of crime could have short-term & personal negative effects, but contribute to lower crime overall. That is why, for example, many countries or companies do not simply capitulate to pirates. Even though it may be far cheaper to just "pay them off," such countries/companies may execute very risky and expensive rescue and recapture operations. And this is largely because they recognize that simply giving in would increase the amount of piracy greatly, and resisting it in this way contributes to detering future piracy.
Obviously there is balance that must be considered on a case-by-case basis.
How would she NOT know it was being repossessed? I'm guessing they tell people before repossessing! This is a ridiculous story.
No they typically do not tell people before repossessing. They just jump in the car and take off, just like a car thief would act.
There was a story in the news a few months ago about a car being repossessed while a toddler still remained in a car seat in the back. That is how quickly it can happen.
I saw one being repo'd once, in a parking lot. They used a tow truck, there were 2 repo men (none of them related to Charlie Sheen) & when the car "owner" came out, they gave him paperwork. The car was already hooked up & ready to roll. Maybe things have changed since then, or maybe it depends on who is contracted to do the repo'ing & who they do it for.
I sent a small donation to the woman who's kid was in the car when it was repo'd that Resident referred to. I received a lovely thank you note from the young mother. I hope she is doing well.
Thanks for enlightening me, folks. I guess there should be an element of catching them off guard or there will be a huge argument.
[Portion removed by Palo Alto Online staff.]
Not surprised at all.Do you people know angie?I do and she needs to pump her brakes or full speed ahead crash and burn.Girl you have kids and shouldnt what the heck you think, cause you birth kids makes you a parent,news not at all.You know what you spend time and energy doing and it is not taking care of KIDS or bills.Of course you knew better these people think you may not but i know you.Get some get right girl.Feel sorry for your kids THATS ABOUT IT.
@ G TOWN
Dude, your post bummed me out. It was hard to make out what you were saying, but I could tell that I REALLY wanted to hear what you had to say. Could you please try that again with full sentances and complete thoughts? you have something important there, I want to hear it. Slow down, take your time.
@ Everyone else, please do not give G TOWN a hard time for his post, what he has to say is more imporant than how he says it, except that he needs to be clearer.
If that was HER reaction, I would hate to see how Demonic Williams would have responded. I'm thinking something like Michael Madsen in "Reservoir Dogs," yes? "Stuck in the Repo with You," maybe? That reminds me, RIP Gerry Rafferty.
I totally miss Gerry Rafferty! Palo Alto could use a little Michael Madsen, the sexiest B actor around. Or is it C?
I can see it now...a remake of Repo Man, w/Michael Madsen in the Harry Dean Stanton role.
I grew up a guy who's now a repo man. That's what 12 years of Catholic school can do to a guy. Plus, he was always scared of cats. Who's scared of cats?
I'd like to hear more from G Town about Angie, also. Give us the scoop, G Town!
@JustMe: It's not difficult to decifer. He is saying that the woman lives in drama and doesn't take care of her kids because she is doing other things instead of taking care of her kids and doesn't have a job to pay the bills. He believes that the woman knew her car was being repossessed but lost her temper. He's telling her to turn her life around and do something right because she is a parent and he feels sorry for her kids.
Yikes! 'Oh, Brother' is playing June Cleavers role in Airplane!, translating the comment of another? THIS is why we need kids to stay in school at least through 12th grade....so they can write a cohesive sentence that can be understood by all.
That being said, I have had so many things ripped off that yes, I advocate a stronger response to thieving scum. I'm tired of people appropriating that which rightfully belongs to another, and I'm tired of other people defending those people by calling into play racism, the economy and other factors that are not good excuses for a complete lack of morals and a sense of entitlement like never before. Some thug beat the hell out of an 80 something year old woman in San Jose, because he wanted to rob her. 80 something can't chase you down the street, why not just rob her and leave her alone? Violence is escalating along with most thefts, and people with any common sense are getting very, VERY tired of it.
In the 80's, I worked three jobs while my husband refused to work. I couldn't pay the rent, food for the kids AND the car payment...they came out and repossessed my car too...about 8pm on an August night...I too, chased the guy, but on foot, crying. The feeling of helplessness that comes over a person when that happens is unbelievable, especially if that car is the only thing assisting you in keeping a roof over your head, and food on the table; by taking you to your job/s each day.
Not to say that this woman's response wasn't over the top, it was, but there has to be some middle ground. Some repo's are done by tow truck, others by getting in with a key. The latter is a stupid, dangerous way to repo a car, because it does resemble theft.
Theft IS on the rise in Palo Alto, who knows what she thought?
Let us please define "stronger response".
If we start using excessive force or deadly force whenever we feel some wrong is being committed, we REALLY risk becoming the criminal rather than the victim. We cannot leave it to everyone to define for themselves what a "crime" is, when punishment should be delivered, or what appropriate punishment is. That is chaos and anarchy, and the only ones who will prosper in that situation are the strongest and most ruthless. That is NOT "rule by law". I cannot believe that any rational person would propose that.
What we need is for the justice system to work. that means prisons that are not revolving doors to criminals, courts that are not afraid to use them, and police with enough confidence in the system to go ahead and arrest the criminals. It also means creating an economic and social environment that gives people alternatives to crime, like jobs and something to look forward to in life besides jail.
There are no simple solutions, but taking the law into your own hands is certainly not a good solution. The only time to use force is when you or someone near you is physically threatened.
She used deadly force and endangered the lives of others over a 20 year old POS Corolla worth less than $1900. If the car was being repossessed she must have received numerous late payment letters over it.
If the car was being repossessed it means it didn't belong to her, since she failed to make payments on it. It's highly unlikely she wasn't aware she wasn't keeping her financing commitment and she must have known that at some point she would be losing the car. After acting so foolishly, she is likely to lose her freedom for a few years, instead of losing just a car.
"There are no simple solutions, but taking the law into your own hands is certainly not a good solution. The only time to use force is when you or someone near you is physically threatened."
While that statement makes a lot of sense, (in a perfect world), and yes, what this woman did was certainly stupid, all the same, using force only when physically threatened enables the creeps in our society to take what they want from us, DO what they want to us, all without much fear of reprisal or very much, if any at all, punishment by the joke that our criminal court system has become. I can't believe how people who become proactive in the protection of their property,then have some criminal injured in the commission of a crime against thier property, become the targets of unscrupulous lawyers. Nevermind that if these people hadn't been trying to take something that wasn't theirs in the first place wouldn't have been injured. In this current society, the only people who are penalized, are the innocent.
People always argue that it's the 'loss of property',and that material things are not worth putting a person in prison. It's not just the property that's the issue. Crime against another, no matter what form, is the loss of a personal sense of security, it's a violation of a person's well being, and it's WRONG.
Okay, so I take a bike ride downtown, park and lock my bike, and go into a shop. As I come out of the shop, I see someone removing my bike from the rack and start to ride off. Thinking quickly, (he's about to get away,) I grab a nearby 2x4, swing it around, and catch him in the back of the head, sending him to the pavement. Yeah, I protected my property, defended my rights,.... oh, wait, my bike is still in the rack. His just looked like mine,... Oops, sorry about that,...
All I did was try to follow what you propose, defending my property with violent action, and now I am going to jail for criminal stupidity. Do you really think you never make mistakes? Do you really think that people will never make mistakes in overzealous protection of property? How can you think taking the law into your own hands is a good idea?
@Enough!: here's another take on your desired world:
. . .using force when property is merely threatened enables vigilante creeps in our society to justify whatever violence they want to visit on those who may threaten their property, DO what they want to us, all without much fear of reprisal or very much, if any at all, punishment by the joke that our criminal court system has become. I can't believe how people who use violence with the justification that they're just being proactive in the protection of their property, try to justify their willful injury, even killing, of the person they think is committing a crime against their property, use unscrupulous lawyers to justify that violence. Nevermind that if these people hadn't been trying to entrap someone to "steal" their property, then that alleged criminal wouldn't have tried to take something that wasn't theirs in the first place. In this current society, the only people who are penalized, are the innocent.
Where do you expect those who you'd license to commit violence merely in the protection of their personal property to draw the line? Do they get to draw it? Any justification works? Keep courts out of it, and let victims and criminals fight it out on the street?
Have you ever seen "City of Gold"? I see it as a look at the kind of world others would propose for us.
According to legend, King Arthur is the one who proposed "Might for the right" instead of "Might makes right".
@ENOUGH.You watch to many movies thats why you keep getting ripped off.You read to slow and outdated way of thinking thats why you dont understand.Do you have kids?Kids not a dog.YOU HAVE TIME TO WRITE ON THIS BLOG AND GIVE YOUR OPINION LIKE IT REALY MEANS SOMETHING.Stop watching movies and watch your property and you might stop being so hateful.
The breakdown on repos - I work for an FI
So this is how it goes-
If a person is 2 - 3 months behind on payments or has broken a promise to pay the car will be put out to an agency for pick up.
The agency has papers on hand to produce to law enforcement as to why the vehicle is being picked up. If the agency encounters the owner they have a set for them as well.
If you don't hold the title to your vehicle you don't own it period.
I really want some %^&*( chasing another ^%$#@ throughmy neighborhood rather than shooting randomly at them with the accuracy of the typical gang banger - hit every thing but the target... unless they are a child..........
The repo man should have, when challenged, stopped and shown his authority to repossess.
Walter, doesn't it seem that the repo person couldn't do so, according to this story & the other news reports?
Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.
Post a comment
Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online.
Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information
We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.
Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?
- Barron Park
- Charleston Gardens
- Charleston Meadows
- College Terrace
- Community Center
- Crescent Park
- Downtown North
- Duveneck/St. Francis
- Embarcadero Oaks/Leland
- Esther Clark Park
- Evergreen Park
- Greater Miranda
- Green Acres
- Greendell/Walnut Grove
- Leland Manor/Garland Drive
- Meadow Park
- Monroe Park
- Old Palo Alto
- Palo Alto Hills
- Palo Alto Orchards
- Palo Verde
- South of Midtown
- St. Claire Gardens
- The Greenhouse
- Triple El
- University South
- Woodland Ave. area (East Palo Alto)
- Addison School
- Barron Park School
- Duveneck School
- Egan Middle School (Los Altos)
- El Carmelo School
- Escondido School
- Fairmeadow School
- Gunn High School
- Hoover School
- JLS Middle School
- Jordan Middle School
- Juana Briones School
- Nixon School
- Ohlone School
- Palo Alto High School
- Palo Verde School
- Santa Rita (Los Altos)
- Terman Middle School
- Walter Hays School
- another community
- Another Palo Alto neighborhood
- East Palo Alto
- Los Altos
- Los Altos Hills
- Menlo Park
- Mountain View
- Portola Valley
Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.
Local picks on 2015 Michelin Bib Gourmand list
By Elena Kadvany | 6 comments | 3,343 views
Ode to Brussels Sprout
By Laura Stec | 20 comments | 2,566 views
Go Giants! Next Stop: World Series!
By Chandrama Anderson | 1 comment | 1,910 views
Politics: Empty appeals to "innovation"
By Douglas Moran | 9 comments | 1,217 views
It's Dog-O-Ween this Saturday!
By Cathy Kirkman | 2 comments | 212 views
Home & Real Estate
Shop Palo Alto
Send News Tips
Circulation & Delivery
Mountain View Voice
© 2014 Palo Alto Online
All rights reserved.