Palo Alto Weekly

News - January 7, 2011

Paly grad pushes for school equity as leader in Teach for America

Bobel: Low-income students can excel if teachers change 'mindset and conditions'

by Chris Kenrick

Approaching her Stanford University graduation in 2003, Emily Bobel was poised to accept a job with a biotech firm when she noticed a recruiting poster for Teach for America on campus.

She answered the ad, spent the next three years teaching science in a bleak South Bronx middle school and altered a life trajectory that until then had been pointed toward a career in biotechnology and law.

Seven years later, the 29-year-old Palo Alto High School graduate finds herself at the heart of an education reform movement that is shaking up classrooms in low-income areas across the country.

Bobel, the executive director of Teach for America's Bay Area organization, oversees a "corps" of 400 young teachers on scores of public school campuses, plus an alumni network whose members are occupying principals' offices, launching their own schools and running for school boards.

The former competitive figure skater expresses a visionary's zeal for her cause eradicating educational inequality and little patience with skeptics.

"We think we're different," Bobel said of Teach for America, which last year nationally attracted more than 40,000 applications from college seniors including many from top-ranked universities for 4,500 entry-level teaching jobs in some of the worst-performing schools across the country.

"We think we bring really energetic, vision-driven, deeply passionate individuals, and beyond that it just comes down to effectiveness," she said.

Often criticized for dropping fresh-faced, inexperienced college grads into some of the nation's toughest classrooms and displacing credentialed teachers Teach for America asserts that, on balance, it achieves superior results.

Academic studies have yielded mixed results on Teach for America's effectiveness, and a lively debate continues among scholars.

But Teach for America has been embraced by influential big-city school superintendents, including Joel Klein who headed New York City's public schools from 2002 until last week, and Michelle Rhee, herself a Teach for America alum who led Washington, D.C.'s public schools from 2007 to 2010.

Bobel maintains that the intense summer training, youthful commitment and near round-the-clock work ethic of Teach for America recruits give disadvantaged students a teacher who will go the extra mile to make sure they learn. Corps members are regularly flooded with data about how their students are performing, and asked to adjust their approaches accordingly.

"Data shows that the average growth in one year for kids in low-income communities is 0.4 to 0.5 years. They're mastering about half of the content they should be mastering, so that's why the achievement gap widens," Bobel said.

"By eighth grade, low-income students on average are three grade levels below more affluent peers.

"We've got to overcompensate because they're growing up in poverty. Teach for America aims for 1.5 years of growth in one year triple the average growth currently going on in our schools.

"We need to put many more great teachers in front of our kids, working relentlessly. This is just hard work," she said.

TFA corps members are measured individually on their students' progress, with mixed results.

Beyond the two- to three-year teaching commitment required by Teach for America, Bobel said many Teach for America alumni remain in Bay Area schools as teachers and principals, infusing their reformist mentality into mainstream school systems.

The organization holds a philosophy of "teaching as leadership," aiming to recruit corps members with leadership potential who will advocate for school reform whether they remain in education or ultimately go into other fields.

"What great educators and visionary principals do is similar to what a great CEO would do: set an ambitious goal, invest people around the goal; plan milestones to get to the destination and not just deliver the material, but make sure the kids are where they need to be," Bobel said.

Of 1,300 Bay Area Teach for America alumni, 54 are now principals in area schools, both traditional and charter schools. Another 300 have continued in long-term teaching careers.

In East Palo Alto's Ravenswood City School District, two principals are Teach for America alums.

"We've been in the Oakland Unified School District for 20 years and now 12 percent of the principals in Oakland are TFA alums," Bobel said.

"We need more leadership at the principal level, great visionaries who know how to develop their teachers."

Even among the Bay Area Teach for America alums who move on to careers outside of education, more than half contributed their time or money to the organization last year, she said.

"When all school districts are challenged by budget cuts, it comes down to the extent to which superintendents and principals see Teach for America as adding value and something that can truly move the needle," she said.

"I have a superintendent (in San Jose) who says, 'Whatever budget decisions I have to make, I'm not going to sacrifice TFA.'"

Bobel's own three years of teaching in a beleaguered, South Bronx middle school were an eye-opener for her.

"It was a stark contrast to Jordan Middle School, where I went.

"There were two sets of metal detectors, barbed wire all over the windows, no grass, no blacktop, no joy it looked like a prison."

Bobel was one of five Teach for America corps members on the school's faculty of 50, encountering "a culture of unbelievably low expectations, negativity, lack of organization within the school, with kids literally running up and down the halls.

"And our task was to create an island of excellence, high expectations and learning in this sea of chaos."

As an 8th-grade science teacher, Bobel said she became scrappy, borrowing or stealing resources from any source she could find.

"At that time in Silicon Valley, a lot of the dotcoms were going under and they had extra supplies. We shipped 150 binders from here to my classroom, so all my kids had binders second semester," she said.

At one point, Bobel found herself reduced to grabbing handfuls of the small, half-pencils from the plastic boxes at IKEA.

"My kids didn't even have pencils I didn't even have chalk."

She borrowed a module approach used in her undergraduate human-biology studies at Stanford, teaching units on HIV and substance abuse that were relevant to her students.

She signed up her classes for the U.S. Department of Energy's Minority Outreach Initiative and had students build fuel-efficient model cars in preparation for a visit from a U.S. assistant secretary of energy.

She held after-school hours and Saturday schools. By the end of eighth grade, 123 of her 125 students scored at or above grade level on a comprehensive science test.

"It wasn't easy by any stretch, but my kids were just as talented as any set of kids in Palo Alto. They're just not given the resources or the attention, and no one has the expectation they can succeed. The minute you change that mindset and conditions, the kids are going to rise to it."

Bobel said it is "not obvious" even to her how she ended up so passionate about education reform.

When she chose Teach for America over the biotech job out of college, she recalls that her parents and friends told her, "'You're not cut out for this.'

"The more people told me I was crazy, the more it made me determined," she said.

"I was never the smartest, or the best athlete growing up. But I firmly believed that no matter where you start from, hard work can land you on top of the heap, and that mindset still continues to drive me.

"I grew up confused by the stark differences in education opportunities between Palo Alto and East Palo Alto.

"I knew something wasn't right, and my desire to do the corps stemmed from wanting to impact this and make a positive difference in our country."

Staff Writer Chris Kenrick can be e-mailed at ckenrick@paweekly.com.

Comments

Posted by the wilsons, a resident of Crescent Park
on Jan 10, 2011 at 11:52 am

bravo emily. great stuff. we have terrific admiration for TFA and the impact it is making in students, teachers, administrators, communities. let's close the achievement gap!


Posted by What about all around role model, a resident of another community
on Jan 10, 2011 at 12:23 pm

I applaud that Emily used her resources to obtain supplies for her students,and it sounds like she had little support to conduct her classes.

However, "At one point, Bobel found herself reduced to grabbing handfuls of the small, half-pencils from the plastic boxes at IKEA." Sounds like stealing to me.

I would encourage Emily to re-look at her methods and her position as a role model and question whether condoning stealing is the message she wants to send to young students.

I would imagine that had she approached Ikea and asked them for a donation of pencils, I am almost certain that they would have supported her work.


Posted by John Jacobs, a resident of Adobe-Meadows
on Jan 10, 2011 at 1:27 pm

We need more committed and talented young people like Emily to dedicate themselves to "leveling the playing field" for children who, through no fault of their own, obviously, are victims of poverty and are relegated to attending inferior schools, for the most part. Without such dedication, education will never make enough of a difference to reverse the ever-widening gap between the "haves" and the "have-nots."


Posted by Jane, a resident of University South
on Jan 10, 2011 at 2:18 pm

I don't understand how these people get hired - how do they displace credentialed teachers? Aren't the districts choosing to hire them??


Posted by Paul, a resident of East Palo Alto
on Jan 10, 2011 at 2:50 pm

"At one point, Bobel found herself reduced to grabbing handfuls of the small, half-pencils from the plastic boxes at IKEA."

Yes, that is stealing. And if she was from EPA she would now have a record.

Bigger issue is why do school districts go through TFA. Essentially districts are just hiring temporary uncredentalled teachers. Why do they need TFA to do that? TFA has an annual budget of $190 million. They aren't spending the money on their teachers because the districts pay salary and benefits. So mainly TFA exists to pay it's own staff.


Posted by TFA supporter, a resident of Community Center
on Jan 11, 2011 at 11:56 am

Districts hire TFA corps members because they are energetic, highly motivated and have driven change in the schools they teach in. Many principals want corp members because they have had such a positive impact. The TFA budget does support its staff but also is used for the summer boot camp that its corp members attend-intense training where the corps members live in dorms and start teaching in summer school programs.


Posted by Cheaters, a resident of South of Midtown
on Apr 13, 2013 at 11:24 am

Bravo Emily!

Beware Michelle Rhees, now that her cheating conspiracy to defraud DC taxpayerrs has come to light.

All that just to get herr fave on the cover of Time, an almost dead newsweekly.


Don't miss out on the discussion!
Sign up to be notified of new comments on this topic.

Email:


Post a comment

Posting an item on Town Square is simple and requires no registration. Just complete this form and hit "submit" and your topic will appear online. Please be respectful and truthful in your postings so Town Square will continue to be a thoughtful gathering place for sharing community information and opinion. All postings are subject to our TERMS OF USE, and may be deleted if deemed inappropriate by our staff.

We prefer that you use your real name, but you may use any "member" name you wish.

Name: *

Select your neighborhood or school community: * Not sure?

Comment: *

Verification code: *
Enter the verification code exactly as shown, using capital and lowercase letters, in the multi-colored box.

*Required Fields