Sign up for Express
New from Palo Alto Online, Express is a daily e-edition, distributed by e-mail every weekday.
Sign up to receive Express!


Palo Alto Online Town Square Google
Login | Register
Sign up for eBulletins
Click for Palo Alto, California Forecast
Palo Alto Online News
Increase font Increase font
Decrease font Decrease font
Adjust text size

Do hard times mean more domestic violence?
Counseling, restraining orders save lives when the going gets extra tough, panelists say

Share
One could almost hear a figurative sigh of relief when news filtered into the 16th annual Domestic Violence Council Conference in Santa Clara last Friday that Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger had restored $16.3 million in funding for domestic-violence shelters the day before.

Attendees were hundreds of people who work directly with victims of domestic violence -- social workers, lawyers, judges, therapists.

Although deaths from domestic violence in Santa Clara County dropped to three in 2008 (two in San Jose, one in Mountain View), 10 people have died in 2009.

More than 5,000 cases of domestic violence are reported every year in the county, according to Rolanda Pierre-Dixon, assistant district attorney. That's about 100 cases every week for non-deadly domestic violence, ranging from pushing and shoving to causing injury.

Many abusers are required to attend domestic-violence classes two hours a week for a full year. Missing more than three sessions is a violation of probation, causing the abuser to possibly face up to a year in jail instead of class.

Research shows that counseling is most effective in a group setting, according to David Duran, director of the Positive Solutions Program at Family and Children Services, located in Palo Alto and San Jose.

Group members help keep each other accountable and make healthy behaviors the norm, he said.

Abusive patterns are learned early in life, Duran said.

"This is the same behavior they saw from their fathers and older brothers. This is 'appropriate,'" he said, adding that many abusers feel their pattern of jealousy and possessiveness is justified.

Counseling gets to the root of the problem, said Pierre-Dixon, who has been working on the issue for 24 years. It deals with the abuser's background and belief system that says battering is OK, and it teaches techniques for controlling and "unlearning" behavior. It demonstrates a different way to be in a relationship -- without abuse.

There are no precise statistics on results of programs yet, but Pierre-Dixon said about two-thirds of the less-severe abusers won't be seen in court again.

"But the hard-core one-third will be back," she said. About half of the felony batterers will also return to court, she said.

One panel at last week's conference looked at the impact of a bad economy on domestic violence.

"These are times of high stress," panel moderator Pierre-Dixon said.

"Unemployment is a big problem. It increases levels of aggressiveness, with job strain and financial stress a major contributor to domestic violence," said Steve Baron, former director of Santa Clara County Family Court Services.

He cited a dramatic decrease in fatalities in partner violence between 1992 and 2005 but anticipated that the latest research, due out in two years, will show either a slowed decrease or possible increase.

"When stress goes up, domestic violence goes up," he said.

Judge Carol Overton, presiding judge in the Santa Clara County Criminal Domestic Violence Court, said the economy is an "inappropriate" excuse, with offenders tying their violent behavior to loss of a job rather than taking responsibility for their actions.

She said there is an urgent need for more advocates working on behalf of victims.

"When we look at domestic-violence related homicides, one of the common characteristics is under- or unemployment," said Frank Del Fiugo, chair of the Domestic Violence Council and co-director of A Turning Point, which works with batterers.

The problem is compounded because often clients and their families cannot afford to pay for the very counseling that would help.

"We teach that our beliefs equal our behaviors," he said, adding that if someone believes that there's no chance to find a job in a down economy he won't even try. "We look at where else he is not being accountable."

Judge Sharon Chatman, from Santa Clara County Family Court's Domestic Violence-specialized court, said the economy has impacted family court: She's seeing more brutal felony-level behavior, with the vast majority involving families with children below age 6, and she's seeing precipitating incidents -- loss of job or home -- that crank up the stress.

Chatman described a case where the male partner lost his job and tried to exert control not only through verbal abuse but by physical abuse, including hiding keys to prevent his wife from going to work.

"The good news is in family court we have tremendous resources, particularly where there are children," she said. Those resources include free legal representation to both victim and perpetrator.

"The victim feels isolated, has no choice, wants violence to stop but wants shelter, food," she said, noting that legal representation can also help victims obtain restraining orders.

"Restraining orders save lives. We only hear about the failures," not about who was saved, she said.


Comments

Posted by Earl Richards, a resident of the Palo Alto Hills neighborhood, on Oct 30, 2009 at 10:43 am

Funding for battered women shelters should never have been vetoed in the first place, because most women are smaller than men.


Posted by Don S, a resident of Portola Valley, on Oct 31, 2009 at 12:54 pm

What's wrong with this picture? Police statistics show that domestic violence is down. Women's violence is not down as much. Earlier this year the Judicial Council finished a study that showed domestic-violence classes are ineffective. Progressive Counties where you would expect more use of feminist protocols had the worst scores. Women's violence was highest in these same counties. Less than two percent of arrests are for repeat offenders. Very few homicides are tied to domestic violence. Cars are thousands of times more dangerous. Most domestic violence accusations occur in family court where standards are low, but effective for grabbing children. Use in family court is now 100 times the FBI rates. If economy or employment were the problem, why would these people be stressing counseling? Revenue?


Posted by Fairplay, a resident of the Midtown neighborhood, on Nov 1, 2009 at 8:22 pm

We have the opportunity to change attitudes in palo Alto...why should Palo Alto be a beacon of economic disparity? In the last budget cycle the EMPLOYEES fought for the city council to reinstate the family services program with the words..."we are only as good a community as we serve ythe weakest among us".

Abuse against women and other entities is pervasive... physical and/or emotional...behind doors and out in the open. When we create a negative atmosphere, when we believe women and others are chattel, or unworthy...WHEN WE DO NOT WORK FOR THE COMMON GOOD?...The common good should not be economically determined it should be the standard - that the citizens of Palo Alto wake up to their attitudes,and to their neighbors.

If the children of Palo Alto suffer from the arrogance of attitudes towards other human beings...it's no wonder it becomes pervasive.

You can't selectively pick and choose which people should eat and which should not...and expect all people to have feelings of self worth. I ask that people who are unsatisfied with the tenor of Palo Alto consider their own behaviour, the behaviour of others ... and the pervasive outcome.

It is ironic that spousal abuse become a topic this month...when employee abuse and berating has been the tenor of Palo Alto On-line.

We have the opposrtunity to raise the bar on our community behaviour and the need to speak out for it.


Add a Comment

Name: *
Select your Neighborhood or School Community: * Not sure?
Comment: *
ADVERTISEMENT

This will be replaced by the player.
Visit the Los Altos Kids Club Web site

2007 Awards from the California Newspaper Publishers Association

Palo Alto Weekly

First Place
Local News Coverage
Local Breaking-News Story
Feature Story

Second Place
Feature Story
Environmental Reporting
Sports Coverage
General News Photo
Photo Essay
Freedom of Information

The Almanac

First Place
Environmental Reporting
Editorial Pages
Lifestyle Coverage

Second Place
Environmental Reporting

Mountain View Voice

Second Place
General Excellence
Editorial Comment
Front-Page Design

 

landscape garden design
graphics and computer consulting support
state quarter trading
Palo Alto Online   © 2009 Palo Alto Online
All rights reserved.