News

Police use stun gun in Mountain View brawl

Differing accounts from police, witnesses on whether Taser-like gun was necessary

Police officers used a Taser-type stun gun on a man who allegedly violently resisted arrest during a massive brawl outside the Zen Lounge in Mountain View last Friday, according to a police spokeswoman.

But according to the man who was shocked with the stun gun, and his friend, who says she saw the majority of the incident, Mountain View police used excessive force on a man who was simply trying to go home after a birthday party.

The fracas erupted shortly after 1:30 a.m. on May 18, and quickly got out of hand, said Liz Wylie, public information officer with the Mountain View Police Department.

According to Wylie, the May 18 incident got so wild that police from three nearby cities were called, even after every officer on duty in Mountain View had already arrived. At the height of the melee, officers estimated that about 200 people were engaged with or watching multiple fights in the parking lot behind Zen, in the breezeway leading to Castro Street and out in front of the club.

"Dozens upon dozens" of mostly male patrons were yelling and trying to instigate confrontations with police and other patrons, Wylie said. "It was essentially a mob. This was way more than we could handle, so we asked for assistance."

The mutual aid request brought in seven officers from Sunnyvale, four from Palo Alto and two from Los Altos.

When there were only a handful of officers on the scene, Wylie said police targeted a man they believed played a key role in instigating the alcohol-fueled donnybrook and attempted to place him under arrest -- with the hope that taking him out of the equation might help quell the brouhaha. "If you can find the leader, so to speak, and take them away from the scene, then the whole crowd tends to calm down."

According to the witness, who did not want to give her name, she had left the bar after celebrating her birthday when officers grabbed her friend, Leshawn James.

Wylie said that the man the police were attempting to arrest put up a violent fight -- throwing his elbows and attempting to head-butt the officers. And although the sight of officers making an arrest may have prompted some to leave, Wylie continued, those who did not flee became increasingly hostile toward the police.

James told the Voice he may have struggled to get out of the officers' arms, but only because he felt they had no reason to grab him in the first place. At no time did officers tell him to stop or that he was under arrest before they grabbed him, he said.

"I don't see how I could elbow him when there was one officer holding one arm and there was another officer holding another arm," James said. "I did not try to head-butt them."

James acknowledges that he shouted obscenities at the police, but said he did not instigate any fights. "That's my free speech," he said, adding that all he did was tell the police they had no reason to arrest him. The next thing he can remember, James said, he was being grabbed from behind and slammed into a car.

"There was no reason for there to be five cops on him," said his friend who witnessed the incident. "He wasn't jerking his arms around, throwing any punches or anything like that. Leshawn was not fighting back in any kind of way." Once the officers managed to get James down, she said, one "cop Tasered him a good five times on the back and then moved the Taser to the back of his neck."

According to Wylie, the man elbowed one of the officers in the head, causing an injury with concussion-like symptoms. The struggle went to the ground and one of the officers deployed his stun gun. The initial shot was not effective, and James continued to struggle, so the officer tried twice more. After the third charge the man finally relented, and officers were able to get him into cuffs.

James said he isn't sure whether the first shot was effective or not, nor could he remember much of the subsequent jolts. All he said he remembers was trying to scream for them to stop.

Even with the man police believed to be the main instigator in cuffs, Wylie said, the incident was far from over. While the police were attempting to subdue the man, a crowd of "about 100 people remained at the scene and formed a flash mob around the three officers and the sergeant."

Another man emerged from the crowd, and, according to the report, tried to snatch the stun gun out of the sergeant's hand. After a brief, unsuccessful struggle, the man fled on foot. Wylie said the sergeant was familiar with the man, and had seen him numerous times at Zen.

The officer later tracked down Ethan Mosley, a 22-year-old Mountain View man, arresting him on charges of attempting to disarm a police officer on May 19 at about 8:50 p.m., near the man's home in the 4600 block of North Shoreline Boulevard.

At the scene, police arrested James, a 22-year-old Sunnyvale resident, on charges of battery on an officer causing injury, resisting arrest and being drunk in public.

A 23-year-old Fremont resident, Delroy Parson, was arrested on charges of interfering with an investigation.

Mosley's mother, Wendy Uher, told the Voice that her son had not tried to take the officer's weapon. Rather, she explained, the crowd pushed her son forward and he came in contact with the sergeant before being pushed back.

Wylie said that any time force is used by an officer in the department, there is a full investigation to ensure that nothing improper occurred.

Comments

Posted by Hmmm, a resident of East Palo Alto
on May 26, 2012 at 8:00 pm

Bummer. Sounds like they should rename this club - doesn't sound very zen to me!


Posted by realpa, a resident of Downtown North
on May 27, 2012 at 5:59 am

realpa is a registered user.

First off I just want to say that mountain view police took things way to far. I was right there and it started off by a man telling a officer to leave him alone because he wasnt drunk and saying that if he didnt leave the area he would be arrested. the man told him f u im not drunk. The officer then went up to him and what looked like he whispered something in the mans ear and then grabbed him and threw him against a car with a lot of force smashing him into the trunk of a small red car. he began to resist arrest by yelling an trying to keep his hands away from his back. It took a while to get him down because he wouldnt fall to the ground but then 5 officers fell on top of him and began tazering him. First was a tazer that shoots which they used 2-3 times and THEN AFTER THEY HANDCUFFED HIM THEY TAZED HIM IN THE BACK OF THE NECK WITH A HAND HELD TAZER!!!! this is a discrace to the MVPD. they man from work of mouth ended up with burn marks for them tazering him so long on his neck. when I was watching this the man sounded like he was screaming for his life to stop and they wouldnt. When witnesses pulled out there cameras they stopped and put him in the police car. They knew they were in the wrong and I hope that young man files a huge lawsuit because I will be happy to be a witness. Also there was about 50 people not 200 Zen dosent even have that amount of people in there club on thursdays. To mountain view police department its funny how everyone was asking for your officers badge numbers on scene and NONE of them would give it there answer would be get the F back or ill will arrest you for being drunk!


Posted by bru, a resident of Crescent Park
on May 28, 2012 at 9:32 am

bru is a registered user.

In the evening, especially on weekends Mountain View is getting to be as unpleasant and rowdy as San Jose.

When people get out of line officers need to do something, and they do not need to spend a lot of time or go back and forth with drunks who will blabber all night long.

And by the way drunks looking for attention can whine and scream very loud - as can legimate victims of police brutality - and it is often hard to tell the difference, but other bar patrons are maybe not the best judges or reporters of what happened.

The first knee-jerk reaction of some is to always blame the police, but on the other hand it is a badge of courage for some drunks to make a big show and give the bar patrons who have nothing better to do something to talk about for years.

That said, I do not agree with Police tasering people when they have been subdued - IF that is what actually happened, which I doubt, because people are so quick with their cellphones today if the Police had been tazing the subdued suspect it would likely have been on video or would have been very quick.

But also, when a Police Officer is talking to you, or asks you to do something - you do not tell them to leave you alone. How stupid, bad attitude right from the start. What ought to be happening is that these people's parents should teach them when they are kids so the cops do not have to clean up for people who do not have the sense to live in a society with other people.

I don't blame the Police. Who would want to have to do this for a job, and then have a bunch of drunk bar patrons blowing bad breath at you demanding your badge number, when it is on their badges?


-- By the way, why do I have to type in that irritating verification code when I am already logged in Palo Alto Online ?


If you were a member and logged in you could track comments from this story.

To post your comment, please click here to login

Remember me?
Forgot Password?
or register. This topic is only for those who have signed up to participate by providing their email address and establishing a screen name.

Breastfeeding Tips
By Jessica T | 9 comments | 1,224 views

Who Says Kids Donít Eat Vegetables?
By Laura Stec | 6 comments | 1,066 views

Community Service Helps You, Too
By John Raftrey and Lori McCormick | 1 comment | 823 views

Call it a novel: Dirty Love by Andre Dubus III
By Nick Taylor | 1 comment | 292 views

How Bad Policy Happens
By Douglas Moran | 0 comments | 85 views